Season 3 episode rank

[buffyholic]

Anne - A
Dead Man?s Party - B
Faith, Hope and Trick - B+
Beauty and the Beasts - B+
Homecoming - B
Band Candy - B-
Revelations - B
Lover?s Walk - A
The Wish - A
Amends - A-
Gingerbread - C+
Helpless - A
The Zeppo - A-
Bad Girls - A
Consequences - A
Doppelglandand - A
Enemies - B-
Earshot - A
Choices - A
The Prom - A
Graduation Day 1 - A
Graduation Day 2 - A

[Nina]

Anne - 7.5
Dead Man?s Party - 3
Faith, Hope and Trick - 8
Beauty and the Beasts - 6
Homecoming - 6.7
Band Candy - 7
Revelations - 8
Lover?s Walk - 8
The Wish - 9
Amends - 9.5
Gingerbread - 6
Helpless - 8
The Zeppo - 6.5
Bad Girls - 7.5
Consequences - 8
Doppelgangland - 8.5
Enemies - 9.5
Earshot - 7.5
Choices - 8
The Prom - 8.5
Graduation Day 1 - 9.5
Graduation Day 2 - 10

[lee]

Anne 7.5
Dead mans party 7.5
Faith hope& Trick 9
Beauty &the beast 6
Homecoming 7.5
Band Candy 8.5
Revelations 9
Lovers walk 9.5
The wish 10
Amends 7
Gingerbread 7
Helpless 10
the zeppo 8.5
Bad girls 8.5
Consequences 8.5
Doppelgangland 10
Enemies 9
Earshot 7
Choices 9
Prom 7.5
Grad 1 9.5
Grad 2 9

I would give the whole sesason a 9/10

[litzie]

I thought maybe I'd rank the episodes in order of my favorite to least favorite...instead of just doing the grades. So, in order of best to worst

Band Candy 10 (one of my all-time favorite episodes)
Earshot 10
The wish 9.5
Doppelgangland 9.5
the zeppo 9.0
Anne 8.5
Helpless 8.5
Dead mans party 8.5
Lovers walk 8.0
Grad 1 8.0
Grad 2 8.0
Gingerbread 7.0
Bad girls 7.0
Consequences 7.0
Enemies 7.0
Choices 7.0
Faith hope& Trick 6.5
Homecoming 6.5
Revelations 6.5
Prom 6.0
Beauty &the beast 4.5 (good potential, not good execution)
Amends 3.0 (one of the most boring buffy episodes, for me)

[Ralphie]

Anne - 7.5
Dead Man's Party - 5.5
Faith, Hope and Trick - 7
Beauty and the Beasts - 7
Homecoming - 6.5
Band Candy - 7
Revelations - 8
Lover's Walk - 8.5
The Wish - 9.8
Amends - 9
Gingerbread - 6.5
Helpless - 7.5
The Zeppo - 7.5
Bad Girls - 8
Consequences - 8.5
Doppelg?ngland - 8.8
Enemies - 9.5
Earshot - 8.5
Choices - 7.5
The Prom - 8
Graduation Day Part 1 - 10
Graduation Day Part 2 - 10

[Pandora's_Box]

Anne - 8
Dead Man's Party - 7.5
Faith, Hope and Trick - 3
Beauty and the Beasts - 1.5
Homecoming - 7.5
Band Candy - 7
Revelations - 2.5
Lover's Walk - 5
The Wish - 10
Amends - 6
Gingerbread - 2
Helpless - 8
The Zeppo - 6.5
Bad Girls - 6.5
Consequences - 2.5
Doppelg?ngland - 8.5
Enemies - 7
Earshot - 8.5
Choices - 3.5
The Prom - 9.5
Graduation Day Part 1 - 8
Graduation Day Part 2 - 8.5

[BlasterBoy]

Note that I rate episodes very...nicely. In my book:

10 = perfection
9.5 = amazing
9 = great
8.5 = really good
8 = good
7.5 = okay
7 = bad
6.5/below = various degrees of bad

Anne - 8/10
Dead Man's Party - 7.5/10
Faith, Hope and Trick - 8/10
Beauty and the Beasts - 7.5/10
Homecoming - 6.5/10
Band Candy - 8/10
Revelations - 9.5/10 - one of my favs
Lover's Walk - 9/10
The Wish - 10/10 - another of my favs
Amends - 7.5/10
Gingerbread - 4.5/10
Helpless - 9/10
The Zeppo - 8.5/10
Bad Girls - 9.5/10
Consequences - 9.5/10
Doppelg?ngland - 9/10
Enemies - 9.5/10
Earshot - 8.5/10
Choices - 8.5/10
The Prom - 8.5/10
Graduation Day Part 1 - 10/10
Graduation Day Part 2 - 10/10

[litzie]

Gingerbread - 4.5/10

Wow, so Gingerbread is the only bad ep of season 3? What's so bad about it?

[BlasterBoy]

Wow, so Gingerbread is the only bad ep of season 3? What's so bad about it?

IMO, it's ridiculously silly. The whole premise is pretty dumb, and I hate the "zombie" parents. The only parts I really like are Oz, "MOO", and "Did I get it"?

[skinless]

I thought maybe I'd rank the episodes in order of my favorite to least favorite...instead of just doing the grades. So, in order of best to worst

I like this Idea, So im going to do this too.

1. Enemies
2. The Wish
3. Doppelg?ngland
4. Lover's Walk
5. Helpless
6. The Prom
7. Revelations
8. Consequences
9. Choices
10. Graduation Day 2
11. Anne
12. Dead man's Party
13. Faith, Hope and trick
14. Bad Girls
15. Earshot
16. Grad Day 1
17. Gingerbread
18. Band Candy
19. Beauty and the Beast
20. Homecoming
21. The Zeppo
22. Amends

[LRae12]

1. Dopplegangland ~ 10/10
2. Helpless ~ 10/10
3. Lover's Walk ~10/10
4. Enemies ~ 10/10
5. The Wish ~ 10/10
6. Graduation Day 2 ~ 10/10
7. Graduation Day 1 ~ 10/10
8. Choices ~ 8/10
9. Earshot ~ 8/10
10. The Prom ~ 7/10
11. Revelations ~ 6/10
12. Consequences ~ 5/10
13. Band Candy ~ 5/10
14. Beauty & the Beasts ~ 4.5/10
15. Amends ~ 4/10
16. Bad Girls ~ 4/10
17. Faith, Hope, & Trick ~ 3/10
18. Anne ~ 3/10
19. Dead Man's Party ~ 2.5/10
20. Homecoming ~ 2/10
21. Gingerbread ~ 1/10
22. The Zeppo ~ 0/10

[Fuzzy]

Anne - 9/10
Dead Man?s Party - 9/10
Faith, Hope and Trick - 8/10
Beauty and the Beasts - 8/10
Homecoming - 7/10
Band Candy - 10/10
Revelations - 9/10
Lover?s Walk - 10/10
The Wish - 10/10
Amends - 8/10
Gingerbread - 5/10
Helpless - 8/10
The Zeppo - 8/10
Bad Girls - 8/10
Consequences - 7/10
Doppelglandand - 9/10
Enemies - 8/10
Earshot - 7/10
Choices - 7/10
The Prom - 6/10
Graduation Day 1 - 9/10
Graduation Day 2 - 9/10

[fitri]

22. The Zeppo - Plain bad and boring.
21. Faith, Hope & Trick - A bad start for the Faith character.
20. Beauty & The Beasts - Underrated, but still awful.
19. Anne - Not one of the better season openers.
18. Consequences - Overrated.
17. Band Candy - Fair.
16. Dead Man's Party - Very underrated.
15. Amends - Very underrated.
14. Gingerbread - Good, hilarious episode.
13. Revelations - An episode with a very likable-hatable character, Gwendolyn Post.
12. Bad Girls - Good.

11. Helpless - Very much above par.
10. Lover's Walk - Very good episode.
09. Choices - Interesting, with dark comedy.
08. Graduation Day (1) - A little overrated, but still great.
07. Homecoming - VERY underrated! CORDELIA!
06. Enemies - Great episode.

05. The Prom - A fun episode with an emotional ending.
04. Earshot - Awesome!
03. Doppelg?ngland - Vamp Willow! 'Nuff said.
02. The Wish - Great alternate universe.
01. Graduation Day (2) - Lovely.