Season 2 Episode Rank

[buffyholic]

So, how do you rank the episodes of season 2? Let?s see...

When she was bad - A
Some Assembly Required - B-
School Hard - A
Inca Mummy Girl - B
Reptile Boy - B-
Halloween - A
Lie to Me - A
The Dark Age - C
What?s my Line pt 1 - B-
What?s my Line pt 2 - B-
Ted - B
Bad Eggs - B-
Surprise - A
Innocence - A
Phases - B
BBB - A
Passion - A
Killed by Death - C
I Only have eyes for You - A
Go Fish - B-
Becoming pt 1 - A
Becoming pt 2 - A

[Nina]

When she was bad - A-
Some Assembly Required - B-
School Hard - B+
Inca Mummy Girl - C
Reptile Boy - B-
Halloween - B+
Lie to Me - A-
The Dark Age - B
What?s my Line pt 1 - B+
What?s my Line pt 2 - A-
Ted - B
Bad Eggs - C+
Surprise - A-
Innocence - A+
Phases - B
BBB - A-
Passion - A+
Killed by Death - B+
I Only have eyes for You - A
Go Fish - B- (But the episode is terrible misplaced)
Becoming pt 1 - A
Becoming pt 2 - A+

[BlasterBoy]

Okay, first, I'll give the number ranks....

When She Was Bad - 8/10
Some Assembly Required - 6.5/10
School Hard - 9/10
Inca Mummy Girl - 5.5/10
Reptile Boy - 7.5/10
Halloween - 8/10
Lie To Me - 9.5/10
The Dark Age - 4/10
What's My Line Part 1 - 8.5/10
What's My Line Part 2 - 9/10
Ted - 7/10
Bad Eggs - 7.5/10
Surprise - 9.5/10
Innocence - 10/10
Phases - 7.5/10
Bewitched, Bothered, and Bewildered - 9/10
Passion - 9/10
Killed By Death - 8/10
I Only Have Eyes For You - 8.5/10
Go Fish - 4/10
Becoming Part 1 - 9.5/10
Becoming Part 2 - 10/10

And now for the letter grades....

When She Was Bad - B
Some Assembly Required - D
School Hard - A-
Inca Mummy Girl - F
Reptile Boy - C
Halloween - B-
Lie To Me - A
The Dark Age - F
What's My Line Part 1 - B+
What's My Line Part 2 - A-
Ted - C-
Bad Eggs - C
Surprise - A
Innocence - A+
Phases - C
Bewitched, Bothered, and Bewildered - A-
Passion - A-
Killed By Death - B-
I Only Have Eyes For You - B+
Go Fish - F
Becoming Part 1 - A
Becoming Part 2 - A+

[Pandora's_Box]

I'm gonna do the number grade too, french aren't familiar with the letters system.

When she was bad - 6/10
Some Assembly Required - 2/10
School Hard - 7.5/10
Inca Mummy Girl - 4.5/10
Reptile Boy - 6/10
Halloween - 6.5/10
Lie to Me - 5.5/10
The Dark Age - 3/10
What?s my Line pt 1 - 5/10
What?s my Line pt 2 - 5/10
Ted - 6/10
Bad Eggs - 1.5/10
Surprise - 7/10
Innocence - 8/10
Phases - 1/10
BBB - 7/10
Passion - 10/10
Killed by Death - 6/10
I Only have eyes for You - 7.5/10
Go Fish - 2/10
Becoming pt 1 - 9/10
Becoming pt 2 - 10/10

[NileQT87]

Innocence - A+
Becoming Part 1 - A+
Becoming Part 2 - A+
Passion - A+
I Only Have Eyes For You - A+
Surprise - A+
What's My Line Part 1 - A
What's My Line Part 2 - A
Lie To Me - A
Halloween - B+
School Hard - B+
Bad Eggs - B
When She Was Bad - B
Killed By Death - B-
Bewitched, Bothered And Bewildered - C+
Reptile Boy - C
Some Assembly Required - C
Inca Mummy Girl - C
Phases - C-
Ted - C-
Go Fish - D
The Dark Age - D-

[buffyholic]

I think you?re a little harsh on Inca Mummy Girl. It has its moments and the interaction between Ampata and Xander is sweet and Willow here is also sweet, we also see Oz for the first time.

[Fehmina]

When she was bad - B+
Some Assembly Required - A
School Hard - A+
Inca Mummy Girl - D-
Reptile Boy - A-
Halloween - B+
Lie to Me - C+
The Dark Age - C-
What?s my Line pt 1 - B+
What?s my Line pt 2 - B+
Ted - B-
Bad Eggs - C+
Surprise - B+
Innocence - B+
Phases - B+
BBB - B+
Passion - B-
Killed by Death - B+
I Only have eyes for You - A+
Go Fish - A+
Becoming pt 1 - A+
Becoming pt 2 - A+

[NileQT87]

i actually do love inca mummy girl--but i just love so many episodes even more (my favorite season). i wouldn't have minded ampata sticking around... if she didn't suck people dry. she wasn't really a bad person until her sense of self-preservation made her do something she didn't particularly want to do. i liked the message about buffy and the inca princess having a lot in common. and plus--bonus points for the multicultural costume party, oz, jonathan, xander/ampata, etc...

[fitri]

When She Was Bad - B+
Some Assembly Required - A
School Hard - A+
Inca Mummy Girl - C-
Reptile Boy - B
Halloween - A
Lie to Me - C
The Dark Age - B-
What?s My Line (Parts 1 & 2) - A
Ted - C+
Bad Eggs - B-
Surprise - A
Innocence - A+
Phases - A
Bewitched, Bothered & Bewildered - A+
Passion - A+
Killed by Death - C
I Only Have Eyes for You - A-
Go Fish - B+
Becoming (Parts 1 & 2) - A+

[Ralphie]

I'll do numbers to

When She Was Bad - 8
Some Assembly Required - 6.5
School Hard - 8.5
Inca Mummy Girl - 6.5
Reptile Boy - 7
Halloween - 8.5
Lie to Me - 8.5
The Dark Age - 7.5
What?s My Line Part 1 - 8.8
What?s My Line Part 2 - 9
Ted - 7
Bad Eggs - 7
Surprise - 9
Innocence - 10
Phases - 8.5
Bewitched, Bothered & Bewildered - 8.8
Passion - 10
Killed By Death - 7.5
I Only Have Eyes For You - 9.5
Go Fish - 7
Becoming Part 1 - 10
Becoming Part 2 - 10

[BangelFan2202]

Here's my episode rank

When she was bad - A
Some Assembly Required - B
School Hard - A
Inca Mummy Girl - C
Reptile Boy - A-
Halloween - A
Lie to Me - B
The Dark Age - B-
What?s my Line pt 1 - B
What?s my Line pt 2 - B
Ted - B-
Bad Eggs - A-
Surprise - A
Innocence - A-
Phases - B-
Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered - B
Passion - A
Killed by Death - C
I Only have eyes for You - A
Go Fish - B
Becoming pt 1 - A
Becoming pt 2 - A


-Trish

[Enisy]

When She Was Bad: B
Some Assembly Required: C-
School Hard: B+
Inca Mummy Girl: D
Reptile Boy: D
Halloween: B
Lie to Me: A
The Dark Age: C
What's My Line #1: B
What's My Line #2: B
Ted: C+
Bad Eggs: C-
Surprise: B
Innocence: A+
Phases: C
Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered: B
Passion: A+
Killed by Death: C+
I Only Have Eyes for You: A
Go Fish: D
Becoming #1: A
Becoming #2: A+

[buffyholic]

I also think you?re a little harsh on Go Fish. The demon part is lame but the humor is just hilarious. I think we needeed that episode before the great heartbreak that is Becoming.

[lee]

am i the only 1 who dosnt think I only have eyes 4u isnt that good???

[cd48jj]

When she was bad - A
Some Assembly Required - B-
School Hard - A
Inca Mummy Girl - B
Reptile Boy - A
Halloween - A
Lie to Me - A
The Dark Age - C
What?s my Line pt 1 - A-
What?s my Line pt 2 - B-
Ted - C
Bad Eggs - A
Surprise - B
Innocence - A
Phases - B
BBB - B
Passion - A
Killed by Death - C
I Only have eyes for You - A
Go Fish - C-
Becoming pt 1 - A
Becoming pt 2 - A

[fitri]

When She Was Bad: B
Some Assembly Required: B+
School Hard: A
Inca Mummy Girl: D+
Reptile Boy: B-
Halloween: B+
Lie to Me: B
The Dark Age: C
What's My Line #1: B+
What's My Line #2: A-
Ted: C
Bad Eggs: C-
Surprise: A-
Innocence: A+
Phases: B
Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered: A
Passion: A+
Killed by Death: C-
I Only Have Eyes for You: A
Go Fish: B-
Becoming #1: A-
Becoming #2: A+

[buffyholic]

You could do this with season 3 too. These kind of posts are really popular.

btw, how many of you cry in Becoming? Yeah, I?m such a crybaby.

[alexa]

Hmm

When She Was Bad: A+
Some Assembly Required: C-
School Hard: B-
Inca Mummy Girl: B-
Reptile Boy: B+
Halloween: B
Lie to Me: A-
The Dark Age: B-
What's My Line #1: C+
What's My Line #2: B-
Ted: B
Bad Eggs: C
Surprise: B
Innocence: A+
Phases: C
Bewitched, Bothered and Bewildered: A
Passion: A
Killed by Death: D
I Only Have Eyes for You: B+
Go Fish: B-
Becoming #1: A+
Becoming #2: A+

< I still cry in Becoming also.. and Innocence.. and WSWB

[allthings]

Heres my rank:

When she was bad - A+
Some Assembly Required - C
School Hard - B-
Inca Mummy Girl - B
Reptile Boy - A+
Halloween - A
Lie to Me - A+
The Dark Age - C
What?s my Line pt 1 - B-
What?s my Line pt 2 - B-
Ted - A+
Bad Eggs - B
Surprise - B
Innocence - A
Phases - B-
BBB - A
Passion - A+
Killed by Death - B+
I Only have eyes for You - A+
Go Fish - B-
Becoming pt 1 - B-
Becoming pt 2 - A

[LaJaula]

When She Was Bad A-
Some Assembly Required C+
School Hard A-
Inca Mummy Girl C-
Reptile Boy C
Halloween A-
Lie to Me A
The Dark Age C+
What's My Line Part One B
What's My Line Part Two A
Ted C
Bad Eggs D+
Suprise B+
Innocence A+
Phases B+
Bewitched, Bothered, and Bewildered A
Passion A+
Killed By Death B
I Only Have Eyes For You A-
Go Fish B-
Becoming Part One A
Becoming Part Two A+