Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Best Tim Minear Written Episode

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • The Best Tim Minear Written Episode

    You know the drill.

    Angel

    Season 1 - Eliminated

    Sense and Sensitivity - Eliminated Round 3
    Hero - Eliminated Round 8 (Tie)
    Somnambulist - Eliminated Round 8 (Tie)
    The Prodigal - Eliminated Round 7
    Sanctuary - Eliminated Round 13

    Season 2

    Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been? - Eliminated Round 12
    Darla - Eliminated Round 11 (Tie)
    The Trial - Eliminated Round 11 (Tie)
    Reunion - Eliminated Round 15

    Reprise - Eliminated Round 16
    Epiphany - WINNER!
    Through The Looking Glass - Eliminated Round 10

    Season 3 - Eliminated


    That Old Gang Of Mine - Eliminated Round 2
    Billy - Eliminated Round 5 (Tie)
    Lullaby - Eliminated Round 14
    Couplet - Eliminated Round 1
    Benediction - Eliminated Round 6 (Tie)

    Season 4 - Eliminated

    Home - Eliminated Round 4 (Tie)

    Firefly - Eliminated


    The Train Job - Eliminated Round 4 (Tie)
    Bushwhacked - Eliminated Round 5 (Tie)
    Out Of Gas - Eliminated Round 9
    The Message - Eliminated Round 6 (Tie)

    Vote for your FIVE LEAST FAV EPPYS. I know...hard.
    Last edited by BlasterBoy; 22-09-08, 12:59 AM.

  • #2
    Sense and Sensitivity - funny, but not up to par with the rest of his eppys
    The Prodigal - great flashbacks, but again, not up to par
    That Old Gang Of Mine - really like seeing some Gunn, but his "friends" bugged me
    Couplet - his worst episode; silly nonsense that can just die
    Home - it's the Pilot to this new show, "let's destroy every character that we took 4 years to build, yeah, that's the ticket"

    Comment


    • #3
      Yay first Poster who name isnt Ben.

      Home
      Billy
      Couplet
      The Prodigal
      Benediction
      sigpic

      Comment


      • #4
        Sense and Sensitivity
        Somnambulist
        The Prodigal
        That Old Gang Of Mine
        Home
        sigpic

        Comment


        • #5
          Yay Tim! Also - I have to pick 5 of those?? Yikes!

          Somnambulist
          Hero
          Home
          Couplet
          Benediction
          No power in the 'verse can stop me.

          Comment


          • #6
            Sense and Sensitivity
            Through The Looking Glass
            Couplet
            The Train Job
            Bushwhacked

            Comment


            • #7
              That Old Gang Of Mine
              Sense and Sensitivity
              Bushwhacked
              The Train Job
              The Message

              I never watched Firefly, and I bet that this are great episodes ... but I can't pick another of his Angel episodes. The guy has only great episodes ... only TOGOM is not that great.

              *sits in a corner ... hugging 'Home' ... pets 'Couplet'*
              Last edited by Nina; 25-08-08, 07:04 PM.

              Comment


              • #8
                This is hard and also, I?ve only seen Firefly once.

                Hero - Doyle?s sacrifice is good but the rest is weak
                The Trial - Great stuff, but compared with other episodes, falls a little short
                Couplet - Funny but weak
                Through the Looking Glass - Funny but something is lacking.
                Benediction - I think this is awesome but I have to decide and the rest is just amazing. So, I chose this one.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Sense and Sensitivity
                  Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been?
                  That Old Gang Of Mine
                  Couplet
                  Benediction

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Reprise
                    Couplet
                    Home
                    Benediction
                    Hero
                    sigpic

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by Nina View Post
                      Bushwhacked
                      Out Of Gas
                      The Message

                      I never watched Firefly, and I bet that this are great episodes ... but I can't pick another of his Angel episodes. The guy has only great episodes ... only TOGOM is not that great.

                      *sits in a corner ... hugging 'Home' ... pets 'Couplet'*
                      For Firefly episodes, you pick "Out of Gas" instead of "The Train Job" :eek: Even if you haven't seen Firefly, it's just common sense!

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Do you want me to change it? I just picked the last three.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by Nina View Post
                          Do you want me to change it? I just picked the last three.
                          Well, I think there's a general consensus that "Out of Gas" is fabulous, and "The Train Job" is just decent, so....I'm not *necessarily* asking you to change it Cough! Wink wink!

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by Nina View Post
                            That Old Gang Of Mine
                            Sense and Sensitivity
                            Bushwhacked
                            The Train Job
                            The Message

                            I never watched Firefly, and I bet that this are great episodes ... but I can't pick another of his Angel episodes. The guy has only great episodes ... only TOGOM is not that great.

                            *sits in a corner ... hugging 'Home' ... pets 'Couplet'*

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by BlasterBoy View Post
                              For Firefly episodes, you pick "Out of Gas" instead of "The Train Job" :eek: Even if you haven't seen Firefly, it's just common sense!
                              Not necessarily! DON'T listen to him Nina, I would pick Out of Gas over The Train Job! TTJ isn't that bad at all, and OOG is just painful to watch.....

                              So wow, TM didn't do ANY Buffy epps?

                              That Old Gang of Mine (duh!)
                              Sense and Sesitivity
                              Home
                              Couplet
                              Out of Gas!
                              Promise that you'll return to me.

                              icon by sireesanswar

                              Comment


                              • #16
                                Don't make it hard for me ... next time I'll vote for both ...

                                Comment


                                • #17
                                  ROFL....Sherr, that's just you!

                                  I'm guessing that either Lullaby, Reunion, Reprise, or Epiphany will win.

                                  Round 1:

                                  Couplet - 8
                                  Sense and Sensitivity - 6
                                  Home - 6
                                  That Old Gang Of Mine - 5
                                  Benediction - 5 ( sooo underrated)
                                  The Prodigal - 3
                                  Hero - 3
                                  Somnambulist - 2
                                  Through The Looking Glass - 2
                                  The Train Job - 2
                                  Bushwhacked - 2
                                  Billy - 1
                                  The Trial - 1
                                  Out Of Gas - 1
                                  Are You Now Have You Ever Been? - 1
                                  Reprise - 1
                                  The Message - 1

                                  Couplet is eliminated for Round 1. Yes.

                                  VOTE FOR FIVE!

                                  Comment


                                  • #18
                                    Sense and Sensitivity - funny, but not up to par with the rest of his eppys
                                    The Prodigal - great flashbacks, but again, not up to par
                                    That Old Gang Of Mine - really like seeing some Gunn, but his "friends" bugged me
                                    The Train Job - a decent episode, but everything is waaay too jumbled together, and FOX is dumb to try and make this the Pilot
                                    Home - it's the Pilot to this new show, "let's destroy every character that we took 4 years to build, yeah, that's the ticket"

                                    Comment


                                    • #19
                                      Boo.

                                      That Old Gang Of Mine
                                      Sense and Sensitivity
                                      Bushwhacked
                                      The Train Job
                                      Out of Gas

                                      Comment


                                      • #20
                                        Reprise
                                        Home
                                        Benediction
                                        Hero
                                        The Train Job
                                        sigpic

                                        Comment

                                        Working...
                                        X