Buffy DVD: Elimination Game

[fitri]

Just like any other elimination game, except now we play with the Buffy DVDs!

[--------------------------------]

Season One

Disc One: - ELIMINATED ROUND 2
- Welcome to the Hellmouth
- The Harvest
- The Witch
- Teacher's Pet

Disc Two: - ELIMINATED ROUND 12 (TIE)
- Never Kill a Boy on the First Date
- The Pack
- Angel
- I, Robot ... You, Jane

Disc Three: - ELIMINATED ROUND 18 (TIE)
- The Puppet Show
- Nightmares
- Out of Mind, Out of Sight
- Prophecy Girl

Season Two

Disc One: - ELIMINATED ROUND 17 (TIE)
- When She Was Bad
- Some Assembly Required
- School Hard
- Inca Mummy Girl

Disc Two: - ELIMINATED ROUND 20 (TIE)
- Reptile Boy
- Halloween
- Lie to Me
- The Dark Age

Disc Three: - ELIMINATED ROUND 10
- What's My Line (1)
- What's My Line (2)
- Ted
- Bad Eggs

Disc Four: - ELIMINATED ROUND 26
- Surprise
- Innocence
- Phases
- Bewitched, Bothered, Bewildered

Disc Five: - ELIMINATED ROUND 25 (TIE)
- Passion
- Killed by Death
- I Only Have Eyes for You
- Go Fish

Disc Six:
- Becoming (1)
- Becoming (2)

Season Three

Disc One: - ELIMINATED ROUND 13 (TIE)
- Anne
- Dead Man's Party
- Faith, Hope & Trick
- Beauty and the Beasts

Disc Two: - ELIMINATED ROUND 21 (TIE)
- Homecoming
- Band Candy
- Revelations
- Lover's Walk

Disc Three: - ELIMINATED ROUND 23
- The Wish
- Amends
- Gingerbread

Disc Four: - ELIMINATED ROUND 18 (TIE)
- Helpless
- The Zeppo
- Bad Girls
- Consequences

Disc Five: - ELIMINATED ROUND 28
- Doppelg?ngland
- Enemies
- Earshot
- Choices

Disc Six:
- The Prom
- Graduation Day (1)
- Graduation Day (2)

Season Four

Disc One: - ELIMINATED ROUND 11
- The Freshman
- Living Conditions
- The Harsh Light of Day
- Fear, Itself

Disc Two: - ELIMINATED ROUND 17 (TIE)
- Beer Bad
- Wild at Heart
- The Initiative
- Pangs

Disc Three: - ELIMINATED ROUND 22
- Something Blue
- Hush
- Doomed

Disc Four: - ELIMINATED ROUND 9
- A New Man
- The I In Team
- Goodbye, Iowa
- This Year's Girl

Disc Five: - ELIMINATED ROUND 19
- Who Are You?
- Superstar
- Where the Wild Things Are
- New Moon Rising

Disc Six: - ELIMINATED ROUND 25 (TIE)
- The Yoko Factor
- Primeval
- Restless

Season Five

Disc One: - ELIMINATED ROUND 7
- Buffy vs. Dracula
- Real Me
- The Replacement
- Out of My Mind

Disc Two: - ELIMINATED ROUND 21 (TIE)
- No Place Like Home
- Family
- Fool for Love
- Shadow

Disc Three: - ELIMINATED ROUND 5
- Listening to Fear
- Into the Woods
- Triangle

Disc Four: - ELIMINATED ROUND 15
- Checkpoint
- Blood Ties
- Crush
- I Was Made to Love You

Disc Five:
- The Body
- Forever
- Intervention
- Tough Love

Disc Six: - ELIMINATED ROUND 24 (TIE)
- Spiral
- Weight of the World
- The Gift

Season Six

Disc One: - ELIMINATED ROUND 12 (TIE)
- Bargaining (1)
- Bargaining (2)
- After Life
- Flooded

Disc Two: - ELIMINATED ROUND 27
- Life Serial
- All the Way
- Once More, With Feeling
- Tabula Rasa

Disc Three: - ELIMINATED ROUND 1
- Smashed
- Wrecked
- Gone

Disc Four: - ELIMINATED ROUND 8
- Doublemeat Palace
- Dead Things
- Older and Faraway
- As You Were

Disc Five: - ELIMINATED ROUND 14
- Hell's Bells
- Normal Again
- Entropy
- Seeing Red

Disc Six: - ELIMINATED ROUND 21
- Villains
- Two to Go
- Grave

Season Seven

Disc One: - ELIMINATED ROUND 16
- Lessons
- Beneath You
- Same Time, Same Place
- Help

Disc Two: - ELIMINATED ROUND 24 (TIE)
- Selfless
- Him
- Conversations with Dead People
- Sleeper

Disc Three: - ELIMINATED ROUND 4
- Never Leave Me
- Bring on the Night
- Showtime

Disc Four: - ELIMINATED ROUND 3
- Potential
- The Killer In Me
- First Date
- Get It Done

Disc Five: - ELIMINATED ROUND 6
- Storyteller
- Lies My Parents Told Me
- Dirty Girls
- Empty Places

Disc Six: - ELIMINATED ROUND 13 (TIE)
- Touched
- End of Days
- Chosen

[--------------------------------]

Pick five of your least favourite DVDs.

[fitri]

In order from the worst of the worst to the best of the worst:

Season Seven, Disc Four:
- Easily the worst disc in the whole of Buffyverse. The disc starts off with Potential, which is a little underrated, but still below average. It continues with the The Killer In Me, an episode I find disgusting because I really prefer Willow/Tara - and Kennedy sucks! First Date and Get It Done, two turkey (and boring) episodes, round up the disc.

Season Five, Disc Three:
- Listening to Fear is arguably the worst episode in this wonderful season. Triangle, no matter how underrated it is, is still a below-average episode. Into the Woods is an okay episode, but nevertheless, this disc is still one of the more rustic ones.

Season Six, Disc Three:
- I think it's a very largely-agreed opinion that the three episodes in this disc, sucks at the very best. Although Wrecked and Gone are extremely underrated in my opinion, this is still a turkey disc.

Season One, Disc One:
- In a season that is almost void of any masterpieces, this is probably the worst DVD. For one, it has The Harvest, Witch and Teacher's Pet (my worst Buffy episode) in it. But then again, this disc begins my favorite TV show, so....

Season Four, Disc Four:
- I dislike Riley, so it makes sense for me to be voting against this disc, as it includes two Riley-heavy episodes (The I In Team and Goodbye, Iowa). The brilliance of This Year's Girl alone is not enough to compensate for this disc.

[Revan]

Season 2 Disk 1: School Hard is the only decent episode on this disk. But it isn't brilliant enough to carry the other eps.

Season 4 Disk 2[/B] Nothing Memorable at all in this disk except possibly beer bad for the comedy that's how far I stretch!

Season 5 Disk 1: Another slow start to a good season.

Season 6 Disk 4: I didn't like this disk because it's pretty much the most depressive moment in all of the seasons.

Season 7 Disk 4: Same as Fitri

[BlasterBoy]

OMG this will be so much fun! Obviously, Seasons 6 and 7 are not favorites, but Season 6 has some of the best discs ever. Disc 2, 5, and 6 are fabulous!

Season 1, Disc 1 - sorry, but "Witch" and "Teacher's Pet" are stunningly horrible. WttH is okay, but "The Harvest" is also bad Horrible.

Season 6, Disc 3 - Oh my god! HORRIBLE! "Smashed" makes me puke, "Gone" also really bad, and "Wrecked", while a bit underrated, is far from good. The only thing that saves this disc is the fantastic special features that come with it. But, it's still in my bottom 5.

Season 6, Disc 4 - again, a disc with really bad episodes. DMP is horrible, Dead Things is good, but not a fav, O&FA is average, like DT. But, As You Were is also really bad. 1/2 is bad. 1/2 is okay.

Season 7, Disc 3 - ah, BotN/Showtime is a very bad two-parter where nothing happens. BORING! And DUMB! Also, NLM is pretty bad, too.

Season 7, Disc 4 - worst DVD of the series. Potential is average, IMO, but The Killer In Me, Get It Done, and First Date all rank in my bottom ten.

[fitri]

Season 1 Disk 2. Personaly I like the pack and angel is average but the other 2 are quite bad. I don't mind the first season and 3/4 of the episodes aren't that bad IMO. But this disk has 2 of my least fav eps.

Season 2 Disk 1: School Hard is the only decent episode on this disk. But it isn't brilliant enough to carry the other eps.

Season 3 Disk 1: A slow start to the seasom IMO


Season 4 Disk 2 Nothing Memorable at all in this disk except possibly beer bad for the comedy that's how far I stretch!

Season 5 Disk 1: Another slow start to a good season.

Season 6 Disk 4: I didn't like this disk because it's pretty much the most depressive moment in all of the seasons.

Season 7 Disk 4: Same as Fitri

Revan, only five discs please.

[BlasterBoy]

Season Five, Disc Three:
- Listening to Fear is arguably the worst episode in this wonderful season. Triangle, no matter how underrated it is, is still a below-average episode. Into the Woods is an okay episode, but nevertheless, this disc is still one of the more rustic ones.

Season Four, Disc Four:
- I dislike Riley, so it makes sense for me to be voting against this disc, as it includes two Riley-heavy episodes (The I In Team and Goodbye, Iowa). The brilliance of This Year's Girl alone is not enough to compensate for this disc.

Season 5, Disc Three: Well, I, personally, thoroughly enjoy LtF due to the emotional part of it, like Buffy's breakdown. Triangle is underrated like you say and HILARIOUS! Not below average, IMO. ItW is a fabulous goodbye to Riley, and the last five minutes may be one of the best endings to a Buffy episode ever!

Yeah, I agree with this cause I hate "A New Man" and "Goodbye Iowa", but I love "This Year's Girl" too much to vote for it

[fitri]

Season 5, Disc Three: Well, I, personally, thoroughly enjoy LtF due to the emotional part of it, like Buffy's breakdown. Triangle is underrated like you say and HILARIOUS! Not below average, IMO. ItW is a fabulous goodbye to Riley, and the last five minutes may be one of the best endings to a Buffy episode ever!

Well, it has been a while since I watched this disc. Maybe I should give this another spin..

[Ojuice5001]

Season Two, Disc Five (sure, it has Passion, but it also has Killed by Death and I Only Have Eyes for You--both of which I skip)
Season Five, Disc Two
Season Five, Disc Three
Season Six, Disc One
Season Seven, Disc One

[ShinyFirefly]

Season Seven: Disc Three
Season Seven: Disc Four
Season Six: Disc Three
Season Six: Disc Four
Season One: Disc One

[skinless]

interesting Idea Fitri.

Season 2 Disc 3:
Season 6 Disc 3:
Season 5 Disc 3:
Season 7 Disc 3:
Season 4 Disc 4:

Um I Think I see a theme in my post.

[Ralphie]

Season 1: Disc 1

Season 4: Disc 1

Season 4: Disc 2

Season 6: Disc 3

Season 7: Disc 5

[Nina]

Season 1: Disc 1
Season 6: Disc 3
Season 6: Disc 4
Season 7: Disc 4
Season 7: Disc 5

[fitri]

Round 1 Results

Season 6, Disc 3 - 6
Season 1, Disc 1 - 5
Season 7, Disc 4 - 4
Season 5, Disc 3 - 3
Season 6, Disc 4 - 3
Season 7, Disc 3 - 3
Season 4, Disc 4 - 2
Season 7, Disc 5 - 2
Season 2, Disc 3 - 1
Season 2, Disc 5 - 1
Season 4, Disc 1 - 1
Season 4, Disc 2 - 1
Season 5, Disc 2 - 1
Season 6, Disc 1 - 1
Season 7, Disc 1 - 1

As expected, Season 6, Disc 3 is the first eliminated disc. This disc contains the two-parter Smashed and Wrecked, and rounded up with Gone.

[--------------------------------]

Pick five of your least favourite DVDs.

[Nina]

Season 1: Disc 1
Season 7: Disc 3
Season 6: Disc 4
Season 7: Disc 4
Season 7: Disc 5

[fitri]

In order from the worst of the worst to the best of the worst:

Season Seven, Disc Four:
- Easily the worst disc in the whole of Buffyverse. The disc starts off with Potential, which is a little underrated, but still below average. It continues with the The Killer In Me, an episode I find disgusting because I really prefer Willow/Tara - and Kennedy sucks! First Date and Get It Done, two turkey (and boring) episodes, round up the disc.

Season Five, Disc Three:
- Listening to Fear is arguably the worst episode in this wonderful season. Triangle, no matter how underrated it is, is still a below-average episode. Into the Woods is an okay episode, but nevertheless, this disc is still one of the more rustic ones.

Season One, Disc One:
- In a season that is almost void of any masterpieces, this is probably the worst DVD. For one, it has The Harvest, Witch and Teacher's Pet (my worst Buffy episode) in it. But then again, this disc begins my favorite TV show, so....

Season Four, Disc Four:
- I dislike Riley, so it makes sense for me to be voting against this disc, as it includes two Riley-heavy episodes (The I In Team and Goodbye, Iowa). The brilliance of This Year's Girl alone is not enough to compensate for this disc.

Season Six, Disc One:
- Season six's starter, Bargaining (1) was great, but it ran out of juice halfway through part two. Flooded was just below average, while After Life was just average.

[Ralphie]

Season 1: Disc 1

Season 5: Disc 1

Season 5: Disc 3

Season 7: Disc 4

Season 7: Disc 5

[LRae12]

Season 4, Disc 6
Season 3, Disc 1
Season 5, Disc 3
Season 7, Disc 3
Season 7, Disc 4

[BlasterBoy]

Season 1, Disc 1 - sorry, but "Witch" and "Teacher's Pet" are stunningly horrible. WttH is okay, but "The Harvest" is also bad Horrible.

Season 3, Disc 1 - Bad start to a great season.

Season 6, Disc 4 - again, a disc with really bad episodes. DMP is horrible, Dead Things is good, but not a fav, O&FA is average, like DT. But, As You Were is also really bad. 1/2 is bad. 1/2 is okay.

Season 7, Disc 3 - ah, BotN/Showtime is a very bad two-parter where nothing happens. BORING! And DUMB! Also, NLM is pretty bad, too.

Season 7, Disc 4 - worst DVD of the series. Potential is average, IMO, but The Killer In Me, Get It Done, and First Date all rank in my bottom ten.

[Pandora's_Box]

Love the idea!!

Season 5 Disc 1:
My ultimate worst episode plus three sucky to go with.

Season 1 Disc 1:
Bad, as simple as that.

Season 1 Disc 2:
Almost as bad except for The Pack whch is just not very good.

Season 4 Disc 4:
The boring disc, the three last episodes makes me wanna take a long nap...

Season 5 Disc 3:
Because there's two average episodes and an awful one (Triangle)

[fitri]

Season 5 Disc 4:
Because there's two average episodes and an awful one (Triangle)

Lol, I think you meant Season 5, Disc 3.