RANK IT! Yep, It's Back!

[LRae12]

All right, back by popular demand, it's RANK IT!!!!

How this game works is I will list things, and you will rank them in order from favorite (1) to least favorite (whatever # is last). I will then tally them up by assigning points to each of your rankings. If we were to rank 10, for instance, than the episode you ranked first would receive 10 points, the second, 9 and so forth. I will do this with everyone's votes, and then average the results, giving us our RANK for each list.

If we get enough participation, we will not only do the seasons for both btvs and ats, but a total rank it, best of, etc.....and then we may move onto characters, seasons, etc. So, are you ready to play RANK IT????


First up, we will start with the BTVS seasons. Since I don't like to do anything normally, we will go in random order.....

So, up first is Season 2:

When She Was Bad
Some Assembly Required
School Hard
Inca Mummy Girl
Reptile Boy
Halloween
Lie to Me
The Dark Age
What's My Line Part 1
What's My Line Part 2
Ted
Bad Eggs
Surprise
Innocence
Phases
Bewitched, Bothered, & Bewildered
Passion
Killed by Death
I Only Have Eyes for You
Go Fish
Becoming Part 1
Becoming Part 2


Remember, to rank them from 1. Favorite to 22. Least Favorite! Are You ready?

RANK IT!!

[LRae12]

1. Innocence
2. Becoming Part 2
3. Passion
4. I Only Have Eyes for You
5. Halloween
6. Surprise
7. School Hard
8. When She Was Bad
9. What's My Line Part 2
10. Lie to Me
11. Bewitched, Bothered, & Bewildered
12. Becoming Part 1
13. What's My Line Part 1
14. Phases
15. The Dark Age
16. Inca Mummy Girl
17. Killed by Death
18. Reptile Boy
19. Bad Eggs
20. Go Fish
21. Some Assembly Required
22. Ted

[holypotatoes]

I don't know if I've played rank it! If I did, it was when someone pm'd me for some help 'cause I can't remember this game.

1.) Becoming Part 2
2.) Innocence
3.) When She Was Bad
4.) Passion
5.) Becoming Part 1
6.) Killed by Death
7.) Surprise
8.) Bewitched, Bothered, & Bewildered
9.) School Hard
10.) I Only Have Eyes for You
11.) Reptile Boy
12.) What's My Line Part 2
13.) What's My Line Part 1
14.) The Dark Age
15.) Halloween
16.) Lie to Me
17.) Phases
18.) Ted
19.) Go Fish
20.) Bad Eggs
21.) Some Assembly Required
22.) Inca Mummy Girl

[fitri]

22. Inca Mummy Girl
21. The Dark Age
20. Bad Eggs
19. Killed by Death
18. Ted
17. Reptile Boy
16. Go Fish
15. Phases
14. Some Assembly Required
13. What's My Line? (1)
12. Lie to Me
11. When She Was Bad
10. Hallowe'en
09. I Only Have Eyes For You
08. What's My Line? (2)
07. Becoming (1)
06. School Hard
05. Passion
04. Surprise (1)
03. Bewitched, Bothered & Bewildered
02. Innocence (2)
01. Becoming (2)

Fun!

[Ojuice5001]

Love this game!

1. Becoming, Part 2
2. Bewitched, Bewildered, and Bothered
3. Inca Mummy Girl
4. Halloween
5. Becoming, Part 1
6. Bad Eggs
7. School Hard
8. Surprise
9. Innocence
10. Phases
11. Passion
12. Go Fish
13. Reptile Boy
14. The Dark Age
15. Ted
16. When She Was Bad
17. What's My Line, Part 1
18. What's My Line, Part 2
20. Some Assembly Required
21. I Only Have Eyes for You
22. Killed by Death

[Nina]

1. Passion
2. Innocence
3. Becoming, part 2
4. Becoming Part 1
5. Suprise
6. I Only Have Eyes For You
7. Bewitched, Bothered, & Bewildered
8. What's My Line, part 2
9. Lie to Me
10. Halloween
11. Schoolhard
12. What's My Line, part 1
13. When she was Bad
14. Some Assembly Required
15. Killed by Death
16. Phases
17. The Dark Age
18. Ted
19. Reptile Boy
20. Bad Eggs
21. Go Fish
22. Inca mummy Girl

What an arc and great bad guys can do with a season ... it's one of the best seasons but it has 6 or 7 weak episodes.

[selenspuffy]

Loved it!

1.Innocence
2.Passion
3.Surprise
4.Phases
5.Becoming Part 1
6.What's My Line Part 2
7.Becoming Part 1
8.What's My Line Part 1
9.School Hard
10.I Only Have Eyes For You
11.The Dark Age
12.Killed By Death
13.Lie To Me
14.Ted
15.Reptile Boy
16.Some Assembly Required
17.Go Fish
18.Bad Eggs
19.Inca Mummy Girl
20.Killed By Death
21.Halloween
22.Bewitched, Bothered, & Bewildered

[Enisy]

Wow, Season 2 has more lame episodes than I remembered... I had trouble ranking them.

1) Innocence
2) Becoming Part 2
3) Passion
4) Lie to Me
5) I Only Have Eyes for You
6) Becoming Part 1
7) School Hard
8) When She Was Bad
9) Halloween
10) Surprise
11) What's My Line Part 2
12) What's My Line Part 1
13) Bewitched, Bothered & Bewildered
14) Ted
15) Killed by Death
16) Phases
17) The Dark Age
18) Bad Eggs
19) Reptile Boy
20) Some Assembly Required
21) Inca Mummy Girl
22) Go Fish

[Retrograde]

1. Passion
2. I Only Have Eyes for You
3. The Dark Age
4. Phases
5. Halloween
6. When She Was Bad
7. Lie to Me
8. Becoming Part 1
9. School Hard
10. Becoming Part 2
11. Ted
12. Surprise
13. Innocence
14. What's My Line Part 1
15. What's My Line Part 2
16. Bewitched, Bothered, & Bewildered
17. Killed by Death
18. Go Fish
19. Inca Mummy Girl
20. Bad Eggs
21. Reptile Boy
22. Some Assembly Required

[Ralphie]

Ah Season 2 my favorite season

1. Becoming Part 2
2. Innocence
3. Passion
4. Becoming Part 1
5. I Only Have Eyes For You
6. Surprise
7. What's My Line Part? 2
8. What's My Line Part? 1
9. Bewitched, Bothered, & Bewildered
10. Lie to Me
11. School Hard
12. Halloween
13. Phases
14. When She Was Bad
15. Killed by Death
16. The Dark Age
17. Reptile Boy
18. Ted
19. Some Assembly Required
20. Bad Eggs
21. Go Fish
22. Inca Mummy Girl

[Chosen1]

Yay!!!! I love this game!


1. Passion
2. Halloween
3. School Hard
4. Lie to Me
5. Becoming Part 2
6. Becoming Part 1
7. What's My Line Part 2
8. What's My Line Part 1
9. The Dark Age
10. Innocence
11. Surprise
12. Phases
13. Bewitched, Bothered, & Bewildered
14. Reptile Boy
15. Some Assembly Required
16. Inca Mummy Girl
17. I Only Have Eyes for You
18. Killed by Death
19. Go Fish
20. Ted
21. Bad Eggs
22. When She Was Bad

[Pandora's_Box]

Yay for Laurie!!

1 - Becoming Part 2
2 - Passion
3 - Becoming Part 1
4 - Innocence
5 - I Only Have Eyes for You
6 - Bewitched, Bothered, & Bewildered
7 - School Hard
8 - Ted
9 - Surprise
10 - When She Was Bad
11 - Halloween
12 - Killed by Death
13 - What's My Line Part 2
14 - What's My Line Part 1
15 - Lie to Me
16 - Inca Mummy Girl
17 - Reptile Boy
18 - Bad Eggs
19 - Some Assembly Required
20 - The Dark Age
21 - Go Fish
22 - Phases

[LRae12]

1 Becoming Part 2 ~ average score: 20.09
2 Passion ~ average score: 19.73
3 Innocence ~ average score: 18.73
4 Becoming Part 1 ~ average score: 16.91
5 Surprise ~ average score: 15.64
6 School Hard ~ average score: 15.18
7 I Only Have Eyes for You ~ average score: 14.45
8 Halloween ~ average score: 13.55
9 Bewitched, Bothered, & Bewildered ~ average score: 13
10 What's My Line Part 2 ~ average score: 12.64
11 Lie to Me ~ average score: 12.18
12 When She Was Bad ~ average score: 11.82
13 What's My Line Part 1 ~ average score: 11
14 Phases ~ average score: 10
15 The Dark Age ~ average score: 8.73
16 Ted ~ average score: 7; statistical average: 6.78
17 Killed by Death ~ average score: 7; statistical average: 6.56
18 Reptile Boy ~ average score: 6.55
19 Inca Mummy Girl ~ average score: 5
20 Bad Eggs ~ average score: 4.82
21 Some Assembly Required ~ average score: 4.73
22 Go Fish ~ average score: 4.27


So for those of you who haven't played before, for a tie-breaker, I throw out the highest and lowest score for the two episodes in question and re-average them, giving the statistical average. If there is still a tie after that, then the episode with the next highest score gets the tie breaker.

So, for S2, we have Becoming 2 taking the lead over Passion and Innocence in 2nd and 3rd place. Becoming Part 1 and Surprise round out the top 5. Go Fish finished up dead last, with Some Assembly Required, Bad Eggs, Inca Mummy Girl and Reptile Boy also fairing poorly. Lie to Me and When She Was Bad were our middle-of-the-road episodes this round.

To let you all see the differences the last time we played, the results were:

1 Becoming Part 2 20.8
2 Passion 20.3
3 Innocence 19
4 Becoming Part 1 17.7
5 Suprise 15.5
6 Halloween 15.2
7 School Hard 15.1
8 What's My Line Part 2 14
9 Bewitched, Bothered, & Bewildered 12.9
10 I Only Have Eyes for You 12.7
11 What's My Line Part 1 12.5
12 Lie to Me 12
13 When She Was Bad 11
14 Phases 9.2
15 Killed by Death 6.9
16 Reptile Boy 6.2
17 The Dark Age 6
18 Go Fish 5.5
19 Some Assembly Required 5.4
20 Inca Mummy Girl 5.1 5
21 Ted 5.1 4.5
22 Bad Eggs 4.9

So, exact ordering for the top 5, but slightly different for the bottom...



Next up, we will rank Btvs Season 5:

Buffy vs. Dracula
Real Me
The Replacement
Out of My Mind
No Place Like Home
Family
Fool for Love
Shadow
Listening to Fear
Into the Woods
Triangle
Checkpoint
Blood Ties
Crush
I Was Made to Love You
The Body
Forever
Intervention
Tough Love
Spiral
The Weight of the World
The Gift

So, RANK IT!

[LRae12]

1. Fool for Love
2. Crush
3. Intervention
4. Buffy vs. Dracula
5. The Body
6. Out of My Mind
7. Tough Love
8. The Gift
9. Forever
10. Real Me
11. Blood Ties
12. Triangle
13. No Place Like Home
14. I Was Made to Love You
15. Spiral
16. Checkpoint
17. Shadow
18. The Weight of the World
19. Family
20. The Replacement
21. Listening to Fear
22. Into the Woods

[BlasterBoy]

Aww, if I were here, Innocence would SO be #2! Thanks for bringing back this game!

1. The Gift
2. The Body
3. Fool For Love
4. Intervention
5. Spiral
6. No Place Like Home
7. Blood Ties
8. I Was Made To Love You
9. Checkpoint
10. Family
11. Into The Woods
12. Tough Love
13. Forever
14. Real Me
15. Triangle
16. The Weight of the World
17. Listening To Fear
18. Shadow
19. Out of My Mind
20. The Replacement
21. Buffy vs. Dracula
22. Crush

[skinless]

1. The Gift
2. Fool For Love
3. Forever
4. Family
5. Blood Ties
6. The Body
7. Spiral
8. The Weight of the World
9. Checkpoint
10. Crush
11. No Place Like Home
12. Buffy Vs Dracula
13. Into The Woods
14. The Replacement
15. Out of Mind
16. I Was Made to Love You
17. Real me
18. Triangle
19. Shadow
20. Intervention
21. Tough Love
22. Listening to Fear

[Nina]

1. Forever
2. The Body
3. Intervention
4. The Gift
5. Fool for Love
6. Checkpoint
7. I Was Made to Love You
8. Spiral
9. Blood Ties
10. Family
11. Tough Love
12. Into the Woods
13. Triangle
14. Shadow
15. Listening to Fear
16. Crush
17. Out of My Mind
18. No Place Like Home
19. Real Me
20. The Replacement
21. The Weight of the World
22. Buffy vs. Dracula

[Pandora's_Box]

01. The Body
02. The Gift
03. Intervention
04. Spiral
05. Forever
06. Fool For Love
07. Crush
08. Listening To Fear
09. The Weight of The World
10. Into The Woods
11. No Place Like Home
12. Blood Ties
13. Shadow
14. Family
15. Checkpoint
16. Out of My Mind
17. I Was Made To Love You
18. The Replacement
19. Real Me
20. Triangle
21. Tough Love
22. Buffy vs. Dracula

[Retrograde]

1. Family
2. The Body
3. The Replacement
4. Fool for Love
5. The Gift
6. Triangle
7. Intervention
8. Crush
9. No Place Like Home
10. Real Me
11. Into the Woods
12. Checkpoint
13. Spiral
14. Shadow
15. Out of My Mind
16. Blood Ties
17. I Was Made to Love You
18. The Weight of the World
19. Tough Love
20. Forever
21. Buffy vs. Dracula
22. Listening to Fear

[Ralphie]

1. The Gift
2. The Body
3. Fool For Love
4. Forever
5. Checkpoint
6. Spiral
7. No Place Like Home
8. Tough Love
9. Triangle
10. Blood Ties
11. Family
12. The Replacement
13. Listening to Fear
14. Shadow
15. Real Me
16. Crush
17. Into the Woods
18. I Was Made to Love You
19. Out of My Mind
20. Intervention
21. The Weight of the World
22. Buffy vs Dracula