The WINNER of Buffy Episode Idol!

[.Tom]

Once More, With Feeling has won Buffy Episode Idol.


The musical extravaganza beat favourite Hush by one vote! In third place came The Body, in joint fourth Prophecy Girland Doppelg?ngland and last (with no votes), Conversations With Dead People.

Thanks to everyone who voted, a very surprising result I'm sure many of you will agree.

[BlasterBoy]

I don't. *sigh*

[Ojuice5001]

Keep in mind, Blasterboy, that Once More with Feeling had an unfair advantage in the semifinal round. That round pitted two episodes from each season up against each other--but as written, the two Season Six episodes were Once More With Feeling vs. The Gift. So for obvious reasons, people voted for Once More With Feeling, and it won that round by default because there was no qualified opponent for the title of "Best Season Six episode."

[holypotatoes]

WELL THAT'S JUST CRAP! There's no way OMWF is the best Buffy episode.

[Pandora's_Box]

Since it's one of the four Whedon's master pieces, I'm okay with it!
Great thread Tom and kickin' banner!!

[Enisy]

Well, it's Joss's favourite episode (that and Innocence) for a reason.

[skinless]

I Dont agree with that. Anything but that Episode (Excluding The Body)

[.Tom]

Keep in mind, Blasterboy, that Once More with Feeling had an unfair advantage in the semifinal round. That round pitted two episodes from each season up against each other--but as written, the two Season Six episodes were Once More With Feeling vs. The Gift. So for obvious reasons, people voted for Once More With Feeling, and it won that round by default because there was no qualified opponent for the title of "Best Season Six episode."

Well actually you're wrong there.

Very few people voted before I corrected the result and even then their vote for season 6 was not counted.

[buffyholic]

I agree with the result. I?m not sure if it?s the best episode ever, but it?s one of the best.