Page 24 of 32 FirstFirst ... 142223242526 ... LastLast
Results 461 to 480 of 628

Thread: Best Episodes of AtS

  1. #461
    Well Spiked Stoney's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Location
    Blighty
    Posts
    7,280
    Thanks
    8,911
    Thanked 10,850 Times in 4,427 Posts

    Default

    - Birthday
    + Sleep Tight

    Billy 11
    Quickening 4
    Lullaby 7
    Birthday 2
    Waiting in the Wings 6
    Loyalty 8
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 7
    The Price 6
    A New World 4
    Benediction 8
    Tomorrow 5

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    12.
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:

  2. #462
    and her haircut. Nina's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    The Netherlands
    Posts
    6,211
    Thanks
    2,091
    Thanked 3,361 Times in 1,139 Posts

    Default

    - Birthday
    + Tomorrow

    Billy 11
    Quickening 4
    Lullaby 7
    Birthday 1
    Waiting in the Wings 6
    Loyalty 8
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 7
    The Price 6
    A New World 4
    Benediction 8
    Tomorrow 6

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    12.
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:

  3. #463
    Slayer Priceless's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2017
    Posts
    3,135
    Thanks
    6,144
    Thanked 5,790 Times in 2,792 Posts

    Default

    + Birthday
    - Loyalty

    Billy 11
    Quickening 4
    Lullaby 7
    Birthday 2
    Waiting in the Wings 6
    Loyalty 7
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 7
    The Price 6
    A New World 4
    Benediction 8
    Tomorrow 6

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    12.
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:

  4. #464
    Slayer Supporter vampmogs's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Location
    Australia
    Posts
    12,221
    Thanks
    1,620
    Thanked 7,408 Times in 2,244 Posts

    Default

    Birthday is such a let down for me. Not only for the problems I've already expressed about Cordy's arc but as far as AU episodes go, this episode is so uninspired. Cordy is pretty much exactly the same in the AU as she is in our reality after having fought evil and harbouring the visions for the past 3 years and, yet, we've been told repeatedly that Cordy's growth as a character is a result of both of those things. So why then is TV actress Cordy (a life that would have just amplified her negative traits had she found success in City Of...) no different? Furthermore, why would she feel so compelled that she "has to see Angel" when realistically she'd have barely thought about him once in 3 years and in City Off... she couldn't care a less about chatting with him and brushed him off? And that was a much shorter period of time after they had been in each other's orbits in Sunnydale. Her randomly kissing him also made no sense as did Angel going crazy from the visions without any explanation as to why.

    And the AU world itself felt very lazy and uninspired. I would've liked more time exploring the world then the episode rushing through it and reversing things so quickly.

    + Forgiving
    - Birthday

    Billy 11
    Quickening 4
    Lullaby 7
    Birthday 1
    Waiting in the Wings 6
    Loyalty 7
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 8
    The Price 6
    A New World 4
    Benediction 8
    Tomorrow 6

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    12.
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:
    "You've got ... a world of strength in your heart. I know you do. You just have to find it again. Believe in yourself."

  5. The Following User Says Thank You to vampmogs For This Useful Post:

    Dipstick (09-11-18)

  6. #465
    Slayer
    Join Date
    Jun 2008
    Posts
    2,377
    Thanks
    3,743
    Thanked 2,994 Times in 1,322 Posts

    Default

    + Loyalty
    - Birthday (gone)

    Billy 11
    Quickening 4
    Lullaby 7
    Waiting in the Wings 6
    Loyalty 8
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 8
    The Price 6
    A New World 4
    Benediction 8
    Tomorrow 6

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    11.
    12. Birthday
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:[/QUOTE]

  7. #466
    and her haircut. Nina's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    The Netherlands
    Posts
    6,211
    Thanks
    2,091
    Thanked 3,361 Times in 1,139 Posts

    Default

    Quickening -
    Benediction +

    Billy 11
    Quickening 3
    Lullaby 7
    Waiting in the Wings 6
    Loyalty 8
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 8
    The Price 6
    A New World 4
    Benediction 9
    Tomorrow 6

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    11.
    12. Birthday
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:

  8. #467
    Slayer TimeTravellingBunny's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Posts
    5,681
    Thanks
    5,123
    Thanked 4,367 Times in 2,040 Posts

    Default

    Quickening -
    Lullaby +

    Billy 11
    Quickening 2
    Lullaby 8
    Waiting in the Wings 6
    Loyalty 8
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 8
    The Price 6
    A New World 4
    Benediction 9
    Tomorrow 6

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    11.
    12. Birthday
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:
    You keep waiting for the dust to settle and then you realize it; the dust is your life going on. If happy comes along - that weird unbearable delight that's actual happy - I think you have to grab it while you can. You take what you can get, 'cause it's here, and then...gone.

  9. #468
    Well Spiked Stoney's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Location
    Blighty
    Posts
    7,280
    Thanks
    8,911
    Thanked 10,850 Times in 4,427 Posts

    Default

    + Loyalty
    - Quickening

    Billy 11
    Quickening 1
    Lullaby 8
    Waiting in the Wings 6
    Loyalty 9
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 8
    The Price 6
    A New World 4
    Benediction 9
    Tomorrow 6

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    11.
    12. Birthday
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:

  10. #469
    Slayer
    Join Date
    Jun 2008
    Posts
    2,377
    Thanks
    3,743
    Thanked 2,994 Times in 1,322 Posts

    Default

    + Loyalty
    - Quickening (gone)

    Billy 11
    Lullaby 8
    Waiting in the Wings 6
    Loyalty 10
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 8
    The Price 6
    A New World 4
    Benediction 9
    Tomorrow 6

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    10.
    11. Quickening
    12. Birthday
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:

  11. #470
    and her haircut. Nina's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    The Netherlands
    Posts
    6,211
    Thanks
    2,091
    Thanked 3,361 Times in 1,139 Posts

    Default

    The Price - (Not a huge fan of glowing Cordelia)
    Lullaby +


    Billy 11
    Lullaby 9
    Waiting in the Wings 6
    Loyalty 10
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 8
    The Price 5
    A New World 4
    Benediction 9
    Tomorrow 6

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    10.
    11. Quickening
    12. Birthday
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:

  12. #471
    Slayer Priceless's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2017
    Posts
    3,135
    Thanks
    6,144
    Thanked 5,790 Times in 2,792 Posts

    Default

    - Loyalty
    + Billy

    Billy 12
    Lullaby 9
    Waiting in the Wings 6
    Loyalty 9
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 8
    The Price 5
    A New World 4
    Benediction 9
    Tomorrow 6

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    10.
    11. Quickening
    12. Birthday
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:

  13. #472
    Slayer TimeTravellingBunny's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Posts
    5,681
    Thanks
    5,123
    Thanked 4,367 Times in 2,040 Posts

    Default

    It would help if I could remember some of these in more detail... I remember I liked Connor in season three, but I'll take the word for glowing Cordelia (I can't remember that at all). I need to refresh my memory watching ASR's reaction videos, I'm a bit behind on them.

    - The Price
    + Benediction

    Billy 12
    Lullaby 9
    Waiting in the Wings 6
    Loyalty 9
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 8
    The Price 4
    A New World 4
    Benediction 10
    Tomorrow 6

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    10.
    11. Quickening
    12. Birthday
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:
    You keep waiting for the dust to settle and then you realize it; the dust is your life going on. If happy comes along - that weird unbearable delight that's actual happy - I think you have to grab it while you can. You take what you can get, 'cause it's here, and then...gone.

  14. #473
    Slayer
    Join Date
    Jun 2008
    Posts
    2,377
    Thanks
    3,743
    Thanked 2,994 Times in 1,322 Posts

    Default

    I prefer Tomorrow and A New World to leave before The Price. Glowy!Cordelia is annoying in The Price but she's mainly just a last minute deux ex machina solution. Cordelia plays a very small part in the ep and her glowing barely takes any screentime. Most of The Price is filled with good stuff. The A-plot about the Sluks is one of the most terrifying MoTWs of the series, It's chilling to see them murder a man in graphic detail, and then nearly kill Fred. It's one of the best uses of the largeness of the Hyperion. Most AtS scenes just occur in the lobby- so the Hyperion is a comforting luxurious looking base. The Sluks are really scary in the Hyperion because the sluks can go to all of the rooms and hallways and their nooks and crannies that AI usually doesn't venture on screen. It's chilling that Angel refuses to take any moral responsibility for the sluks and says that he'd do it again and it's further chilling that only Lorne even tries to call Angel out on his mistakes. However here, I do feel satisfied that the show is calling out Angel because Lorne is giving voice to that. It's great foreshadowing that Fred nearly dies from the sluks brought on by Angel's choices, and then, Fred actually dies from going to W&H, Angel's executive decision. The Gunn/Wesley scenes are excellent. AD *kills* me in that monologue of how he fought to stay alive after the throat slashing so he could explain what happened to his friends. I think this is Gunn's most interesting episode in S3 because he disagrees with Angel, advances his own POV and then, takes his own action to save Fred instead of just being a follower, and has an angry conversation with Wesley, tinged by Fred-triangle issues, but not only about Fred-triangle-issues.

    Tomorrow, on the other hand, has Cordelia as like a B-plot. And she glows there too! LOL. The C-plot Wesley/Lilah stuff is all great. The scripting and AD's/SR's performance is perfect and on rewatch, it really struck me as amazing that Wesley and Lilah had such immediate chemistry and personality-kismet when they never interacted until A New World. The A-plot Connor stuff is great from Connor's perspective where he's a fully rounded character, pretending to make peace with Angel but seething about Holtz and biding his time to imprison Angel. However, I find Super Happy!Angel pretty flat in that plot and Gunn/Fred are basically cardboard cut-outs of support. DB's performance doesn't wow me and he's distracted with the B-plot Cangel stuff. It feels like Angel is just mainly hitting a bunch of fatherly cliches with Connor. I mean, he was *trying*. I'm not entirely bashing him. However, I really didn't find much delightful or interesting about Happy! Reunited! Father! Angel.

    The B-Plot Cangel/Cordelia stuff is terrible. It's better with the S4 retcon. At least, we now know that we're not supposed to believe that ONLY Cordelia between the Scoobies and AI and Gunn's old gang and other slayers is a pure and radiant enough saint that she gets to Ascend. At least, we're not supposed to believe that Cordelia is too good for *humanity*. Bur even with the S4 retcon, it's annoying. Charisma's performance is awful. I still don't get the purpose of Apartment!Cordelia talking to Long White Dress!Cordelia in dribs and drabs of I'm in love! With Angel! It's very disappointing that this is the last Real Cordelia episode that we get (until You're Welcome as a one-off) and she's just so...crappy. It's works in a story about Cordelia being corrupted by her own importance that she just leaves her whole life in Skip's say-so of her importance. However, I think there was a way to tell that story but still have Cordelia ask Skip some questions about who'd get the visions and what can can she do for humanity and her friends once she Ascends that she can't do on earth as a human. Cordelia is rendered so annoying and up her own a*s that even the unmistakable tragedy of what happened to her doesn't hit me even if it becomes much better as a tragedy than the straight triumph that it's presented in Tomorrow.

    + The Price
    - Tomorrow

    Billy 12
    Lullaby 9
    Waiting in the Wings 6
    Loyalty 9
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 8
    The Price 5
    A New World 4
    Benediction 10
    Tomorrow 5

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    10.
    11. Quickening
    12. Birthday
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:

  15. The Following User Says Thank You to Dipstick For This Useful Post:

    TimeTravellingBunny (09-11-18)

  16. #474
    and her haircut. Nina's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    The Netherlands
    Posts
    6,211
    Thanks
    2,091
    Thanked 3,361 Times in 1,139 Posts

    Default

    While I agree that the Cordy stuff in Tomorrow is also horrible, the Connor stuff makes me rate Tomorrow higher than The Price. I for one like it that Connor kind of takes over the show in Tomorrow and season 4 while Angel disappears a bit in the background until Home.


    - The Price
    + Tomorrow

    Billy 12
    Lullaby 9
    Waiting in the Wings 6
    Loyalty 9
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 8
    The Price 4
    A New World 4
    Benediction 10
    Tomorrow 6

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    10.
    11. Quickening
    12. Birthday
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:

  17. The Following User Says Thank You to Nina For This Useful Post:

    TimeTravellingBunny (09-11-18)

  18. #475
    Scooby Gang bespangled's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2015
    Location
    Tucson, AZ
    Posts
    505
    Thanks
    1,076
    Thanked 1,300 Times in 499 Posts

    Default

    Waiting in the Wings +
    A New World -

    Billy 12
    Lullaby 9
    Waiting in the Wings 7
    Loyalty 9
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 8
    The Price 4
    A New World 3
    Benediction 10
    Tomorrow 6

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    10.
    11. Quickening
    12. Birthday
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:[/QUOTE]
    Bottom line is, even if you see them coming, you're not ready for the big moments...The big moments are gonna come, you can't help that. It's what you do afterwards that counts. That's when you find out who you are.

  19. #476
    Well Spiked Stoney's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Location
    Blighty
    Posts
    7,280
    Thanks
    8,911
    Thanked 10,850 Times in 4,427 Posts

    Default

    - Tomorrow
    + A New World

    Billy 12
    Lullaby 9
    Waiting in the Wings 7
    Loyalty 9
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 8
    The Price 4
    A New World 4
    Benediction 10
    Tomorrow 5

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    10.
    11. Quickening
    12. Birthday
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:

  20. #477
    Slayer
    Join Date
    Jun 2008
    Posts
    2,377
    Thanks
    3,743
    Thanked 2,994 Times in 1,322 Posts

    Default

    - Tomorrow
    + Loyalty

    Billy 12
    Lullaby 9
    Waiting in the Wings 7
    Loyalty 10
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 8
    The Price 4
    A New World 4
    Benediction 10
    Tomorrow 4

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    10.
    11. Quickening
    12. Birthday
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:

  21. #478
    Slayer Priceless's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2017
    Posts
    3,135
    Thanks
    6,144
    Thanked 5,790 Times in 2,792 Posts

    Default

    + Billy
    - Loyalty

    Billy 13
    Lullaby 9
    Waiting in the Wings 7
    Loyalty 9
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 8
    The Price 4
    A New World 4
    Benediction 10
    Tomorrow 4

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    10.
    11. Quickening
    12. Birthday
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:

  22. #479
    and her haircut. Nina's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    The Netherlands
    Posts
    6,211
    Thanks
    2,091
    Thanked 3,361 Times in 1,139 Posts

    Default

    The Price -
    Forgiving +

    Billy 13
    Lullaby 9
    Waiting in the Wings 7
    Loyalty 9
    Sleep Tight 8
    Forgiving 9
    The Price 3
    A New World 4
    Benediction 10
    Tomorrow 4

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    10.
    11. Quickening
    12. Birthday
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:

  23. #480
    Well Spiked Stoney's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Location
    Blighty
    Posts
    7,280
    Thanks
    8,911
    Thanked 10,850 Times in 4,427 Posts

    Default

    - Tomorrow
    + Sleep Tight

    Billy 13
    Lullaby 9
    Waiting in the Wings 7
    Loyalty 9
    Sleep Tight 9
    Forgiving 9
    The Price 3
    A New World 4
    Benediction 10
    Tomorrow 3

    Reset at:
    15
    9
    5

    Eliminated:
    10.
    11. Quickening
    12. Birthday
    13. Heartthrob
    14. That Vision Thing
    15. Fredless
    16. Offspring
    17. Dad
    18. Couplet
    19. That Old Gang of Mine
    20. Double or Nothing
    21. Provider
    22. Carpe Noctem

    Results:
    Top 3 of season 1: 3rd - To Shanshu in LA, 2nd - The Prodigal, 1st - Five by Five
    Top 3 of season 2: 3rd - Reprise, 2nd - Darla, 1st - Are You Now Or Have You Ever Been
    Top 3 of season 3:
    Top 3 of season 4:
    Top 3 of season 5:
    Top 3 overall:

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •