View Full Version : Buffy One-by-One -- NEW STYLE
sherrilina
18-05-08, 10:50 PM
I don't hate him!! It's just that it is one of the most empty episodes of BtVS. Seriously, besides the review, what's in it?
Glory visiting Buffy? Buffy kicking ass and pwning Council members? :p
Becoming (2) - 4.5/5
Checkpoint - 3.5/5
basakbangel
19-05-08, 10:02 AM
Becoming 2-5/5
Checkpoint-4/5
buffyholic
19-05-08, 04:17 PM
Becoming 2 - 5/5
Checkpoint - 4/5
chosen_guy
20-05-08, 04:18 PM
I liked it
Becoming - 4 /5
Chckpoint - 4,5/5
skinless
21-05-08, 04:18 AM
ROUND 87 RESULTS:
Becoming Part 2 - 4.75 WINNER! 56 Wins Overall
Checkpoint - 3.65
ROUND 88:
Becoming Part 2 vs. Blood Ties
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Blood Ties - 4/5
sherrilina
21-05-08, 07:37 AM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Blood Ties - 4.5/5
Becoming (2) - 4.5/5
Blood Ties - Never really understood why people underrated this. 4/5
Pandora's_Box
21-05-08, 11:08 AM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Blood Ties - 2/5 One of the few arc's pivotal episodes of the show I don't like, like Revelations or The Initiative.
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Blood Ties - 2.5/5
Ralphie
21-05-08, 02:11 PM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Blood Ties - 2/5
buffyholic
21-05-08, 02:36 PM
Becoming 2 - 5/5
Blood Ties - 5/5
basakbangel
21-05-08, 07:45 PM
BC2-5/5
Blood Ties-3/5
skinless
24-05-08, 05:59 PM
ROUND 88 RESULTS:
Becoming Part 2 - 4.9 WINNER! 57 Wins Overall
Blood Ties - 3.37
ROUND 89:
Becoming Part 2 vs. Crush
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Crush - 4/5
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Crush - 3/5
Ralphie
24-05-08, 06:47 PM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Crush - 2/5
Pandora's_Box
24-05-08, 07:36 PM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Crush - 3/5
basakbangel
24-05-08, 08:42 PM
BC2-5/5
Crush-3.5/5
sherrilina
25-05-08, 01:31 AM
BC2-5/5
Crush-3.5/5
Becoming (2) - 4.5/5
Crush - 3.5/5
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Crush - 4/5
skinless
26-05-08, 06:19 AM
ROUND 89 RESULTS:
Becoming Part 2 - 4.9 WINNER! 58 Wins Overall
Crush - 3.31
ROUND 90:
Becoming Part 2 vs. I Was Made to Love you
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
I Was Made to Love you - 4.5/5
Becoming (2) - 4.5/5
I Was Made to Love You - Under-fricking-rated!! 4/5
Pandora's_Box
26-05-08, 10:10 AM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
I Was Made to Love you - 2/5 (I don't count the last scene since it's The Body's)
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
I Was Made to Love you - 3.5/5
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
I Was Made to Love you - 3/5
Ralphie
26-05-08, 03:03 PM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
I Was Made to Love you - 2.5/5
buffyholic
26-05-08, 07:04 PM
Becoming 2 - 5/5
I was Made to Love you - 4.5/5
Yes! The Body's up next!!!! God, I can't wait!
skinless
26-05-08, 10:23 PM
I know it hasnt been a whole day but Im eager to see how "The Body" will do. So Im giving it till 5:00 and then its Changeover time.
skinless
26-05-08, 11:15 PM
ROUND 90 RESULTS:
Becoming Part 2 - 4.9 WINNER! 59 Wins Overall
I Was Made to Love you - 3.5
ROUND 91:
Becoming Part 2 vs. The Body (Deserves to win at least once)
Becoming Part 2 - 4.5/5
The Body - 5/5
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
The Body - 4/5
Pandora's_Box
27-05-08, 01:28 AM
Becoming Part 2 - 4.5/5 (to make the distinction)
The Body - 5/5
sherrilina
27-05-08, 05:20 AM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5 (because it's better)
The Body - 4/5
sherrilina
27-05-08, 05:21 AM
Becoming Part 2 vs. The Body[/B] (Deserves to win at least once)
Becoming Part 2 - 4.5/5
I Was Made to Love you - 5/5
Ummm....don't you HATE The Body?! :s
Becoming 2 ~ 5/5
The Body ~ 5/5
skinless
27-05-08, 06:24 AM
Ummm....don't you HATE The Body?!
Umm Hate's a strong word, I might dislike it but it doesnt mean it shouldnt win at least once. Read my reveiw on it and it'll tell u why.
sherrilina
27-05-08, 09:05 AM
Umm Hate's a strong word, I might dislike it but it doesnt mean it shouldnt win at least once. Read my reveiw on it and it'll tell u why.
*shrug* You were the one always trying to get rid of it in other games, and have said before you hated it......did you reconsider when you rewatched it?
And I think it's won stuff before....:p
Shhh! Don't make him change his mind!!
Ralphie
27-05-08, 01:48 PM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
The Body - 4/5
buffyholic
27-05-08, 02:09 PM
Becoming 2 - 5/5
The Body - 5/5
very tough decision!!
Becoming Part 2 - 4.5/5
The Body - 5/5
Becoming (2) - 4/5 :p
The Body - 5/5
Pandora's_Box
27-05-08, 06:41 PM
Only for skinless to read!
Sorry, but I need to save The Body!
Becoming (2) - 0.1/5
The Body - 5/5
Oh Fitri, you actually did what I thought of doing...This is bad and unfair but...Good job!!!
To be honest, I really don't like it. (And not only because I like Becoming more), there is almost always a little strategic voting ... people who take 0.2 points of a episode in the hope that the other episode wins ... but isn't the point of the game to let the episode win that the most people like the most?
Maybe I take the game too serious ... but in this battle the winner will be chosen (I don't think that another episode comes by who can beat one of those 2) ... and if the winner is chosen like this ... it's less fun.:(
Awh, okay, find, I'll *try* to vote justly. :p **coughcoughcoughbubbleburstercoughcoughcough**. :p
Pandora's_Box
27-05-08, 06:57 PM
To be honest, I realy don't like it. (And not only because I like Becoming more), there is almost always a little strategic voting ... people who take 0.2 points of a episode in the hope that the other episode wins ... but isn't the point of the game to let the episode win that the most people like the most?
Maybe I take the game too serious ... but in this battle the winner will be chosen (I don't think that another episode comes by who can beat one of those 2) ... and if the winner is chosen like this ... it's less fun.:(
I'd say the problem is that we're voting on a scale of 0 to 5 which is kinda short. I always rated Bec 2 5/5 so far cause I love it and it's in my Top 5, but then it's against The Body which I love more, so I rated Bec 4.5/5 to show the love distinction between both. Okay rating Bec 2 0.1/5 is unfair but after all, we're here to support our favorite episode. The problem is, what if people starts to do tactical votes all over the places...You know what, I'm on your side after all :lol:
Yes, that was my point; somebody giving a 4.5 because they want the other episode to win doesn't end the game, a 0.1 does end the game because there is no way that the episode can be saved after that. And if the episode deserves a 0.1 like IR,YJ or something like that ... fine, but Becoming doesn't deserve a 0.1.
If I'm honest; If the body wins now, I'm probably giving it a 4.5 or something like that as well. :D
Haha lol, I'm up against two people here... Damn! Ah well, vote edited! :p
sherrilina
27-05-08, 09:39 PM
Becoming (2) - 2.5/5 :p (REALLY. Compared to The Body, my ratings for Becoming (2) is this.)
The Body - 5/5
Give me a BREAK! Please vote honestly....if you think The Body is better, give it a 5 vs. a 4 or something! :rolleyes: This kind of thing just makes these games not as fun....
To be honest, I really don't like it. (And not only because I like Becoming more), there is almost always a little strategic voting ... people who take 0.2 points of a episode in the hope that the other episode wins ... but isn't the point of the game to let the episode win that the most people like the most?
Maybe I take the game too serious ... but in this battle the winner will be chosen (I don't think that another episode comes by who can beat one of those 2) ... and if the winner is chosen like this ... it's less fun.:(
No I feel the same way.....if The Body is going to win, it should win fair and square, not through inflated or deflated ratings....
Haha lol, I'm up against two people here... Damn! Ah well, vote edited! :p
That's not much better! :rolleyes:
skinless
27-05-08, 11:39 PM
Yeah Fitri, No offense But the original Creator of this thread, (BlasterBoy) would look down on this as do I. Please vote honestly.... Vote however u want in the Angel Thread but keep this thread truthful, I will tally up the votes later
*cracks under pressure*
Okay, fine... :lol:
skinless
28-05-08, 05:57 AM
this is the Last Chance anyone one has to vote or Edit vote for Either episode. Its Extremly Close. The Closest any Battle has been so far.
NileQT87
28-05-08, 06:03 AM
becoming, pt. 2 = 5/5
the body = 1/5
am i the only one that is totally not a fan of the body? the christmas flashback is practically the only part i really care for. forever is superior in every way.
and becoming (both parts) are some of the most amazing television ever!
skinless
28-05-08, 06:09 AM
ROUND 91 RESULTS:
BEFORE NILEQT87'S Vote
Becoming Part 2 - 4.71
The Body - 4.66
__________________________________________________ _____
After NILEQT87'S Vote
Becoming Part 2 - 4.75 WINNER! 60 Wins Overall
The Body - 4.3
ROUND 92:
Becoming Part 2 vs. Forever (Very Underrated IMO)
Becoming Part 2 - 4/5
Forever - 5/5
NileQT87
28-05-08, 06:12 AM
now this is a bit better... but it's got to be becoming again.
becoming, pt. 2 = 5/5
forever = 4/5
Forever is underrated like crazy! I mean, that last scene with Buffy and Dawn? Oh, God! Brought me to fricking tears!
Becoming (2) - 4/5
Forever - 5/5
skinless
28-05-08, 06:24 AM
Uh yeah it is, I love this episode But we all know at least 1 person will give it a bad score and it will lose. But I hope it does pretty good.
Yeah, me too! I hope it doesn't get like 2.-something...
sherrilina
28-05-08, 07:09 AM
Not a big fan of Forever myself, but it's okay....there aren't really that many flat-out BAD epps in season 5, it's so solid as a whole....
Becoming (2) - 5/5
Forever - 3/5
ShinyFirefly
28-05-08, 08:37 AM
Becoming (2) - 5/5
Forever - 2/5
Becoming (2) - 5/5
Forever - 3/5
Ralphie
28-05-08, 11:00 AM
Becoming (2) - 5/5
Forever - 4/5
I actually prefer Forever over the Body.
Becoming 2 - 5/5
Forever - 4.2/5
Pandora's_Box
28-05-08, 01:42 PM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Forever - 4/5
buffyholic
28-05-08, 04:21 PM
Becoming 2 - 5/5
Forever - 4/5
Yay! Looks like Forever wasn't really underrated afterall!
Becoming 2 ~ 5/5
Forever ~ 2.5/5
skinless
29-05-08, 04:47 AM
ROUND 92 RESULTS:
Becoming Part 2 - 4.8 WINNER! 61 Wins Overall
Forever - 3.7
ROUND 93:
Becoming Part 2 vs. Intervention
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Intervention - 2.5/5
My fault for saying that.. :(
Becoming (2) - 4/5
Intervention - Yerrh... 2.5/
ShinyFirefly
29-05-08, 07:19 AM
Becoming (2) - 5/5
Intervention - 3/5
Pandora's_Box
29-05-08, 10:44 AM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Intervention - 4.5/5 (I love the last scene!)
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Intervention - 4/5
It's with the Buffybot, isn't it? I love that bot. :heart:
Ralphie
29-05-08, 01:35 PM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Intervention - 2.5/5
buffyholic
29-05-08, 01:37 PM
Becoming 2 - 5/5
Intervention - 3.75/5 (the last scene is just pure gold)
Becoming 2 ~ 5/5
Intervention ~ 4.75/5
sherrilina
29-05-08, 08:44 PM
Becoming 2 ~ 5/5
Intervention ~ 4/5
basakbangel
29-05-08, 08:55 PM
BC2-5/5
Intervention 4.5/5( I just love the part where Buffy and Giles go for the f.slayer)
Becoming pt2 5/5
Intervention 3.5/5
skinless
01-06-08, 03:15 AM
ROUND 92 RESULTS:
Becoming Part 2 - 4.9 WINNER! 62 Wins Overall
Intervention - 3.5
ROUND 93:
Becoming Part 2 vs. Tough Love
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Tough Love - 2/5
Ralphie
01-06-08, 03:43 AM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Tough Love - 2/5
sherrilina
01-06-08, 06:09 AM
You give Family a 5 and Tough Love a 2, skinless?! :s
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Tough Love - 4.5/5
skinless
01-06-08, 07:48 AM
You give Family a 5 and Tough Love a 2, skinless?! Yea It just is not all around good for me except for the last 10 mins Sorry Sher. But if it helps, The Next 3 Episodes for me will get a 4 or higher.
Pandora's_Box
01-06-08, 10:42 AM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Tough Love - 1.5/5
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Tough Love - 2/5
Becoming pt2 5/5
Tough love 3/5
Becoming (2) - 4.5/5
Tough Love is seriously underrated. - 4/5
sherrilina
01-06-08, 08:18 PM
Tough Love is seriously underrated. - 4/5
Seriously! :(
Becoming 2 ~ 5/5
Tough Love ~ 3/5
skinless
02-06-08, 06:22 AM
ROUND 93 RESULTS:
Becoming Part 2 - 4.9 WINNER! 63 Wins Overall
Tough Love - 2.75
ROUND 94:
Becoming Part 2 vs. Spiral
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Spiral - 4/5
sherrilina
02-06-08, 09:09 AM
Dude, it's ridonkulous that TL got that low of a score! :down:
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Spiral - 4/5
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Spiral - 3/5
Pandora's_Box
02-06-08, 11:51 AM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Spiral - 5/5 After Chosen, the most epic episode.
Ralphie
02-06-08, 12:19 PM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Spiral - 3.5/5
ShinyFirefly
02-06-08, 12:43 PM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Spiral - 3.75/5
buffyholic
02-06-08, 01:07 PM
Becoming 2 - 5/5
Spiral - 3.75/5
Becoming 2 ~ 5/5
Spiral ~ 2.25/5
becoming 2 5/5
Spiral/ 3.5/5
Becoming (2) - 4.5/5
Spiral - 3.5/5 (I feel this is a bit overrated.. Don't know why..)
skinless
03-06-08, 12:08 AM
ROUND 94 RESULTS:
Becoming Part 2 - 4.9 WINNER! 64 Wins Overall
Spiral - 3.5
ROUND 95:
Becoming Part 2 vs. Weight of the World
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Weight of the World - 4/5
sherrilina
03-06-08, 12:09 AM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Weight of the World - 3.5/5
Ralphie
03-06-08, 12:09 AM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Weight of the World - 2/5
BlasterBoy
03-06-08, 12:52 AM
Hopefully The Gift will knock Becoming out of the park.
Becoming II - 4.5/5 (decided to only give 5s to top 5 of Jossverse :evil: that means it goes to The Body, The Gift, Lullaby, NFA, and Forgiving/Reunion/Reprise)
Weight - 3.5/5 (pretty good)
Becoming 5/5
Weight of... 4/5
Hopefully The Gift will knock Becoming out of the park.
I agree.
Becoming (2) - 4.5/5
Weight of the World - 2/5 (Here's one of the MOST boring episodes in Jossverse.)
Pandora's_Box
03-06-08, 12:27 PM
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Weight of the World - 2/5
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Weight of the World - 2/5
buffyholic
03-06-08, 01:59 PM
Becoming 2 - 5/5
Weight - 4/5
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
Weight of the World - 2.5/5
Becoming 2 ~ 5/5
Weight of the World ~ 2.75/5
skinless
04-06-08, 05:19 AM
ROUND 95 RESULTS:
Becoming Part 2 - 4.9 WINNER! 65 Wins Overall
Weight of the World - 2.9
ROUND 96:
The 2 best of the Finales. Let the best one win.
Becoming Part 2 vs. The Gift
Becoming Part 2 - 3/5
The Gift - 5/5
sherrilina
04-06-08, 07:44 AM
Gee, I wonder which one you want to win! :p
It's a win win situation here, they're about tied for me! :D I'm happy with either one moving forward....
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
The Gift - 5/5
I hope The Gift wins... I'm longing for a twist in the game, so that it's not so predictable (cause this is it - if The Gift doesn't win, B2 will conquer the whole game).
Becoming (Part 2) - 3.9/5
The Gift - 5/5
Pandora's_Box
04-06-08, 10:35 AM
Becoming (Part 2) - 5/5
The Gift - 4.5/5
Ralphie
04-06-08, 12:32 PM
Becoming (Part 2) - 5/5
The Gift - 4.9/5
Becoming 2 ~ 5/5
The Gift ~ 3/5
Becoming Part 2 - 5/5
The Gift - 3.5/5
Becoming 5/5
The Gift 4/5
Becoming Part 2: 4/5
The Gift: 5/5
BlasterBoy
04-06-08, 10:36 PM
Becoming Part 2 - 4.5/5
The Gift - 5/5
If Becoming wins this, it wins. If Gift wins it, it wins. There's no other episode that comes to a 5/5. Only episodes in BtVS that becoming a 5/5 are The Gift and The Body. And for AtS it's Reprise, Reunion, Forgiving, Lullaby, and NFA :lol:
buffyholic
05-06-08, 02:23 PM
Becoming 2 - 5/5
The Gift - 5/5
really hard.
sherrilina
06-06-08, 05:33 AM
I hope The Gift wins... I'm longing for a twist in the game, so that it's not so predictable (cause this is it - if The Gift doesn't win, B2 will conquer the whole game).
I wouldn't necessarily count on that, unless there aren't a lot of epps left....people often get bored and vote for inferior epps, and things get crazy....:rolleyes:
Jenni Lou
07-06-08, 09:11 PM
Becoming 2 - 4.25/5
The Gift - 4.75/5
skinless
07-06-08, 09:18 PM
ROUND 96 RESULTS:
Becoming Part 2 - 4.529-65 Wins Overall
The Gift - 4.570- We Have a New Winner Becoming has been Dethroned!!
ROUND 97:
The Gift vs. Bargaining Part 1
The Gift - 5/5
Bargaining Part 1 - 2/5
Ralphie
07-06-08, 10:07 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Bargaining Part 1 - 2/5
The Gift - 4.5/5 (I actually didn't REALLY love this episode. I guess it's just good.)
Bargaining (1) - 3/5 (Better than what most people give it credit for.)
Buuuuh!
The Gift - 3.5/5
Bargaining Part 1 - 1.5/5
BlasterBoy
08-06-08, 12:16 AM
Fitri, if you just thought The Gift was good, why is it at 4.5/5 for you? :s
The Gift - 5/5
Bargaining (Part 1) - 2.5/5
Gift 4.5/5
Bargaining 4/5(pt 1s great)
Pandora's_Box
08-06-08, 03:30 AM
The Gift - 5/5
Bargaining (Part 1) - 4/5
Fitri, if you just thought The Gift was good, why is it at 4.5/5 for you? :s
It is good, but it doesn't merit a full score for me. I just voted 5 cause I wanted it to win lol.. ;)
sherrilina
09-06-08, 03:08 AM
The Gift - 5/5
Bargaining (Part 1) - 5/5 (waaaaaay underrated apparently! Part 1 was top-notch! :()
skinless
09-06-08, 06:51 AM
ROUND 97 RESULTS:
The Gift - 4.6 - Winner 2 in a row
Bargaining Part 2 - 3.0
ROUND 98:
The Gift vs. Bargaining Part 2
The Gift - 5/5
Bargaining Part 2 - 3/5
sherrilina
09-06-08, 07:15 AM
Man, I can't believe some of the scores B1 got! :(
The Gift - 5/5
Bargaining Part 2 - 3/5
I wonder what will win this round!
The Gift 4.5/5
Bargainning pt 2 3.5/5
Pandora's_Box
09-06-08, 10:41 AM
The Gift - 5/5
Bargaining Part 2 - 4/5
The Gift - 3.5/5
Bargaining Part 2 - 3/5
I wonder what will win this round!
Really??
Becoming (2) - 4.5/5
Bargaining (2) - 3/5
sherrilina
09-06-08, 11:28 AM
Really??
I think that might have bee sarcasm....
Ralphie
09-06-08, 12:45 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Bargaining Part 2 - 2.5/5
buffyholic
09-06-08, 01:36 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Bargaining pt 2 - 4/5
The Gift - 5/5
Bargaining pt 2 - 3.5/5
BlasterBoy
09-06-08, 11:06 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Bargaining (Part 2) - 3/5 (like this one much better; darker)
basakbangel
10-06-08, 06:37 PM
The Gift-5/5
B2-3.5/5
skinless
11-06-08, 01:53 AM
ROUND 98 RESULTS:
The Gift - 4.7 - Winner 3 in a row
Bargaining Part 2 - 3.2
ROUND 99:
The Gift vs. Afterlife
The Gift - 5/5
Afterlife - 4.5/5
The Gift 4.5/5
afterlife 3.5/5
sherrilina
11-06-08, 02:36 AM
The Gift - 5/5
After Life - 3/5
Ralphie
11-06-08, 02:48 AM
The Gift - 5/5
After Life - 3/5
BlasterBoy
11-06-08, 03:37 AM
The Gift - 5/5
After Life - 3/5 (real average)
The Gift ~ 1/5
After Life ~ 5/5
I'm bitter that it beat Becoming 2, what can I say...:p
sherrilina
11-06-08, 07:11 AM
The Gift ~ 1/5
After Life ~ 5/5
I'm bitter that it beat Becoming 2, what can I say...:p
Come on though, it's no fun if you sink the episode with false ratings--if you're bitter give it only .5-1 less than you were giving it previously. :down: We've gone through this before....
The Gift - 4/5
Afterlife - 3.5/5
Pandora's_Box
11-06-08, 12:23 PM
The Gift - 5/5
After Life - 4/5
buffyholic
11-06-08, 01:11 PM
The Gift - 5/5
AfterLife - 5/5
The Gift ~ 4/5
After Life ~ 3/5
I don't get the After Life love! The episode doesn't suck, of course, but it definitely wasn't as good as The Gift.
The Gift - 4.5/5
After Life - 2.5/5
skinless
15-06-08, 04:46 PM
ROUND 99 RESULTS:
The Gift - 4.7 - Winner 4 in a row
Afterlife - 4.0
ROUND 100:
The Gift vs. Flooded
The Gift - 5/5
Flooded - 4/5 (Purely for the Giles/Willow Scene in the Kitchen)
Pandora's_Box
15-06-08, 05:04 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Flooded - 4/5
The Gift - 4/5
Flooded - 3/5
BlasterBoy
15-06-08, 05:52 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Flooded - 1.5/5 (always disliked this one)
The Gift 4.5/5
Flooded 2.5/5
sherrilina
16-06-08, 04:24 AM
Oooh Nina I loove your new adorable Brooth bannerset! :heart:
The Gift - 5/5
Flooded - 2.7/5
basakbangel
16-06-08, 10:47 AM
the gift 5/5
flooded 3/5
Oooh Nina I loove your new adorable Brooth bannerset! :heart:
Thank you. :hug:
buffyholic
16-06-08, 01:20 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Flooded - 3/5
Ralphie
16-06-08, 02:32 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Flooded - 1.5/5
I did not like this one.
The Gift: 4.5/5
Flooded: 2/5
skinless
16-06-08, 05:50 PM
ROUND 100 RESULTS:
The Gift - 4.8 - Winner 5 in a row
Flooded - 2.7
ROUND 101:
The Gift vs. Life Serial
The Gift - 5/5
Life Serial - 2.5/5
The Gift - 4/5
Life Serial - 2/5
Ralphie
16-06-08, 09:54 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Life Serial - 1.5/5
The gift 4.5/5
Life serial 3/5(a fun little eppy)
basakbangel
16-06-08, 10:31 PM
the gift-5/5
life serial-4/5
BlasterBoy
16-06-08, 10:52 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Life Serial - 3.5/5 (very funny)
The Gift 3/5
Life Serial 4/5
The Gift: - 4.5/5
Life Serial: - 4/5 (FUNNY and UNDERRATED!)
Pandora's_Box
17-06-08, 10:32 AM
The Gift - 5/5
Life Serial - 4/5
The Gift - 5/5
Life Serial - 3.5/5
The Gift ~ 3/5
Life Serial ~ 4/5
sherrilina
18-06-08, 02:23 AM
The Gift ~ 5/5
Life Serial ~ 3.5/5
skinless
18-06-08, 04:35 AM
ROUND 101 RESULTS:
The Gift - 4.5 - Winner 6 in a row
Life Serial - 3.2
ROUND 102:
The Gift vs. All the Way
The Gift - 5/5
All the Way - 2.9/5
The Gift 4.5/5
all theway 2.5/5
Gift 3.5/5
All the way 4.5/5
Pandora's_Box
18-06-08, 08:44 AM
The Gift - 5/5
All the Way - 1.5/5
The Gift: 4.5/5
All the Way: Good. Underrated. 3.5/5
Gift - 4/5
All the way - 1/5
Ralphie
18-06-08, 02:46 PM
The Gift - 5/5
All the Way - 1/5
The Gift ~ 3/5
All the Way ~ 2.5/5
The Gift - 5/5
All the Way - 2.5/5
sherrilina
19-06-08, 03:12 AM
The Gift - 5/5
All the Way - 3/5 (underrated, not that bad, but not brilliant either!)
BlasterBoy
19-06-08, 04:05 AM
The Gift - 5/5
All The Way - 1.5/5
ShinyFirefly
19-06-08, 06:54 AM
The Gift - 4/5
All the Way - 1.5/5
ShinyFirefly
19-06-08, 06:55 AM
The Gift ~ 3/5
All the Way ~ 2.5/5
I'm not as big on The Gift as some people but even I think these scores are crazy. :p
The Gift 3/5
All the Way 4/5
skinless
19-06-08, 12:46 PM
ROUND 102 RESULTS:
The Gift - 4.3 - Winner 7 in a row
All the Way - 2.4
ROUND 103:
The Gift vs. Once More With Feeling
The Gift - 4.5/5
Once More With Feeling - 4/5 (Now Were Partying, That's what its all about.) I love The Music but hate the episode
Gosh, this is hard!
The Gift - 3.8/5
Once More, With Feeling - 5/5!
Pandora's_Box
19-06-08, 12:50 PM
The Gift - 4/5
Once More, With Feeling - 5/5
buffyholic
19-06-08, 12:55 PM
Tough call
The Gift - 5/5
Once more with Feeling - 5/5
The Gift - 4/5
Once More With Feeling - 3.5/5
Ralphie
19-06-08, 04:28 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Once More With Feeling - 3/5
basakbangel
19-06-08, 07:24 PM
the gift-5/5
OMWF4/5
BlasterBoy
19-06-08, 10:27 PM
Clément :mad: I thought you loved The Gift! 5/5 to 4/5....HMM! SUSPICIOUS!
The Gift - 5/5
Once, More With Feeling - 2.5/5 (I'm not over exaggerating...)
The Gift - 5/5
Once More, With Feeling - 5/5
The Gift 4.5/5
Once More With Feeling 4/5
The Gift 3.5/5 Never really liked that much
Once more With Feeling 5/5
Pandora's_Box
20-06-08, 08:57 AM
Clément :mad: I thought you loved The Gift! 5/5 to 4/5....HMM! SUSPICIOUS!
The Gift - 5/5
Once, More With Feeling - 2.5/5 (I'm not over exaggerating...)
I like OMWF better so I wanted to give it a shot but I guess Revan sealed the deal.
Does his vote count? I mean ... it's not fair to give this kind of rates.
edit:
his vote is changed.
Clément :mad: I thought you loved The Gift! 5/5 to 4/5....HMM! SUSPICIOUS!
The Gift - 5/5
Once, More With Feeling - 2.5/5 (I'm not over exaggerating...)
No way! Life Serial a 3.5? And a 3 to After Life, which you called average?
I thought you said you liked the episode, it's just that it became repetitive because you kept re-watching it and stuff.. But it's still a good episode right? Well who asked you to play it so many times, lol..?!
The Gift ~ 2/5
Once More Wit Feeling ~ 5/5
BlasterBoy
21-06-08, 04:53 AM
No way! Life Serial a 3.5? And a 3 to After Life, which you called average?
I thought you said you liked the episode, it's just that it became repetitive because you kept re-watching it and stuff.. But it's still a good episode right? Well who asked you to play it so many times, lol..?!
:lol: :roll: Well, I'm trying to be a harsher grader and using the whole scale, so I changed average to 2.5. I don't find it particularly amazing at all. I'm not a huge showtunes fan, so the music doesn't make me want to jump up and down; I mean, I like the music, but not that much. And I would much rather watch another random Buffy episode that that.
skinless
21-06-08, 10:01 AM
ROUND 103 RESULTS:
The Gift - 4.275 - Winner 8 in a row
Once More With Feeling - 4.250
ROUND 104:
The Gift vs. Tabula Rasa
The Gift - 4.5/5
Tabula Rasa - 4.5/5
Awh.. So close... :(
The Gift - 4.5/5
Tabula Rasa - 4.5 (Just a flaming chunk of fun!)
Pandora's_Box
21-06-08, 10:33 AM
The Gift - 4/5
Tabula Rasa - 5/5
The Gift - 4/5
Tabula Rasa - 3/5
The Gift - 5/5
Tabula Rasa - 4/5
Ralphie
21-06-08, 01:57 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Tabula Rasa - 3/5
BlasterBoy
21-06-08, 05:43 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Tabula Rasa - 4/5 (a tad overrated)
sherrilina
21-06-08, 07:59 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Tabula Rasa - 4/5
missperoxide
21-06-08, 08:29 PM
The Gift - 4.5/5
Tabula Rasa - 4.5/5
basakbangel
21-06-08, 10:29 PM
The Gift-5/5
Tabula Rasa 4/5
skinless
23-06-08, 02:39 AM
ROUND 104 RESULTS:
The Gift - 4.65 - Winner 9 in a row
Tabula Rasa - 4.1
ROUND 105:
The Gift vs. Smashed
The Gift - 4.5/5
Smashed - 2/5
BlasterBoy
23-06-08, 02:41 AM
The Gift - 5/5
Smashed - 1.5/5
Ralphie
23-06-08, 03:02 AM
The Gift - 5/5
Smashed - 1.5/5
The Gift - 2.5/5
Smashed - 3/5
The Gift - 5/5
Smashed - 4/5
buffyholic
23-06-08, 03:42 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Smashed - 3/5
The Gift - 4/5
Smashed - 1.5/5
Pandora's_Box
23-06-08, 11:19 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Smashed - 4/5
skinless
23-06-08, 11:58 PM
ROUND 105 RESULTS:
The Gift - 4.5 - Winner 10 in a row
Smashed - 2.5
ROUND 106:
The Gift vs. Wrecked
The Gift - 4.5/5
Wrecked - 2.5/5
The Gift - 4/5
Wrecked - 1/5
Pandora's_Box
24-06-08, 12:03 AM
The Gift - 5/5
Wrecked - 4/5
BlasterBoy
24-06-08, 01:20 AM
The Gift - 5/5
Wrecked - 2/5 (real average, but I hate Willow now, so brings it down)
Ralphie
24-06-08, 03:52 AM
The Gift - 5/5
Wrecked - 1/5
The Gift - 2.5/5
Wrecked - 3.5/5
The Gift - 4.5/5
Wrecked - Underrated. Love the Willow scene at the end. 3.5/5
The Gift - 5/5
Wrecked - 2.5/5
buffyholic
24-06-08, 04:42 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Wrecked - 3/5
icecreamkiller
24-06-08, 06:57 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Wrecked - 3/5
sherrilina
25-06-08, 04:34 AM
The Gift - 5/5
Wrecked - 2.5/5
skinless
25-06-08, 04:44 AM
ROUND 106 RESULTS:
The Gift - 4.5 - Winner 11 in a row
Wrecked - 2.5
ROUND 107:
The Gift vs. Gone
The Gift - 4.5/5
Gone - 1/5
BlasterBoy
25-06-08, 04:45 AM
The Gift - 5/5
Gone - 1.5/5
sherrilina
25-06-08, 04:53 AM
I actually don't mind Gone all that much...I thought it was pretty decent overall!
The Gift - 5/5
Gone - 3.5/5
ShinyFirefly
25-06-08, 08:08 AM
But it's just...so...dumb.
The Gift - 4/5
Gone - 0.5/5
The Gift - 4/5
Gone - 1/5
I actually don't mind Gone all that much...I thought it was pretty decent overall!
Looks like it's just the two of us..
The Gift: 4.5/5
Gone: 3.5/5
Pandora's_Box
25-06-08, 02:05 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Gone - 1.5/5
Ralphie
25-06-08, 02:40 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Gone - 0.5/5
buffyholic
25-06-08, 03:18 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Gone - 2/5
I like Gone as well! Sure it does not take your breath away but I thought it was quite an enjoyable ep. :)
The Gift - 5/5
Gone - 3.5/5
skinless
26-06-08, 08:25 PM
ROUND 107 RESULTS:
The Gift - 4.7 - Winner 12 in a row
Gone - 1.85
ROUND 108:
The Gift vs. Doublemeat Palace
The Gift - 4.5/5
Doublemeat Palace - 1/5
BlasterBoy
26-06-08, 08:57 PM
The Gift - 5/5
Doublemeat Palace - 1.5/5
vBulletin® v3.7.1, Copyright ©2000-2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.